Fallout 3 is by far the game of yea. Yes i have Fable II and Gears of War 2.

200 hours + and still fun. Can't stop playing, i just got GoW 2 but after play Fallout 3.... its not fun at all.

Any objections ?

All I have to say is Metal Gear Solid 4

Haven't played GoW 2 yet, but I've played FO3, Dead Space, The Force Unleashed, and a few other games.  Although different genre's if I had to choose, I would choose Dead Space to be my GOTY, with TFU following in close second.

Haven't played GoW 2 yet, but I've played FO3, Dead Space, The Force Unleashed, and a few other games. Although different genre's if I had to choose, I would choose Dead Space to be my GOTY, with TFU following in close second.

iareconfuse

haha i highly doubt TFU would even make the nominees for the GOTY. I found it very average. 
I think fallout 3 has a major chance...

200 hours + and still fun. Can't stop playing, i just got GoW 2 but after play Fallout 3.... its not fun at all.

Any objections ?

suplax

Since it was released ( October 28 ) about 360 hours have elapsed or 15 days.  You have played 200 hours already?  That's what?  13.33 hours a day.  I think you may have a gaming problem sir.

Fallout 3 is great but i'm with the others that mentioned MGS4 as game of the year. That game was amazing, I'd say that fallout and gears 2 have some what of a chance but game of the year should be MGS4