I would get The Godfather, simply because the first Godfather was far superior to the first Mafia. Ironically, though, the Mafia II "Holiday Confessions" trailer on XBL has made pretty excited for Mafia II, more so, in fact, than I am for The Godfather II. I haven't seen much info/media pertaining to Mafia yet, so my money and anticipation is more with The Godfather. I do have a strong feeling that they'll both end up being mediocre, though. But I'm pretty sure I'll end up buying TGFII close to its release date.
I thought The Godfather game was a horrible piece of cat crap.
Mafia, on the other hand, was a masterpiece. I played Mafia for the PC though, so maybe it was bad on consoles. But Mafia is definitely in my top 5 of best games ever, right next to Deus Ex :)
Godfather 2 is a Day 1 purchase for me. Loved the first one. I never got a chance to play Mafia, but hopefully I will soon and then move on to Mafia 2. Instead of arguing which one is better, I'd rather enjoy them both.
Log in to comment