Mass Effect vs Bioshock vs Halo 3 vs COD4

Alright....my friends have been arguing over this for quite some time. which is the better game? I have heard that Bioshock is one of the best games out there for the 360, but I am going to be honest, I really never played it. I really have not gotten into Mass Effect too much either. But I am familiar with COD4 and Halo 3. I would have to say I believe Halo is better just cause I play it more. The only reason I am throwing the other two in the mix is cause I am tired of hearing people talk about COD4 and Halo 3 (and plus my friends insist to throw those 2 in the mix). So from what I have heard and my own knowledge, here is my order:

Halo 3>COD4>Bioshock>Mass Effect

Whats your guys' order?

COD4>ME>H3>Bio

Bioshock is last cuz, although the game is outstanding it leaves little for replay value. ME, however, is so fekkin involving you immediately replay it after you complete it.

wow that is a really hard decision. ok as far as singleplayer i'd say ME>bio>halo3>CoD4

but as far as the whole package id go with CoD>ME>Halo3>bioshock

bioshock is an awesome experience but like the guy already said, after i beat it once i didnt play it again. and if CoD4 had co-op and the singleplayer was a little longer than it would be way higher for the singleplayer. overall though, these are probly 4 of the top ten games on 360 right now, you cant go wrong with any of them.

BioShock>ME>CoD4>Halo 3

Honestly.. Halo 3 was a horrible game thats why it's last. I only played the Beta for CoD4 and I hated it, but still it was better then the entire SP campaign in Halo. Mass Effect was mediocre, it was so promising but full of letdown.. The only game out of all 4 of these that I enjoyed from begining to end is BioShock which could explain why im on my 3rd play through... well that and lack of games.

BioShock>ME>CoD4>Halo 3

Honestly.. Halo 3 was a horrible game thats why it's last. I only played the Beta for CoD4 and I hated it, but still it was better then the entire SP campaign in Halo. Mass Effect was mediocre, it was so promising but full of letdown.. The only game out of all 4 of these that I enjoyed from begining to end is BioShock which could explain why im on my 3rd play through... well that and lack of games.

cleotis_max

That's your opinion. I, along with a number of other people. Hated Bioshock. All of this is just simple opinion.

[QUOTE="cleotis_max"]

BioShock>ME>CoD4>Halo 3

Honestly.. Halo 3 was a horrible game thats why it's last. I only played the Beta for CoD4 and I hated it, but still it was better then the entire SP campaign in Halo. Mass Effect was mediocre, it was so promising but full of letdown.. The only game out of all 4 of these that I enjoyed from begining to end is BioShock which could explain why im on my 3rd play through... well that and lack of games.

Relys

That's your opinion. I, along with a number of other people. Hated Bioshock. All of this is just simple opinion.

....okay? That's fantastic. Thanks for the most pointless post on Gamespot.

Great. It's his opinion. So let him have it without you quoting him and having to "clarify" that it's JUST AN OPINION and Bioshock, according to you, sucks.

Thanks.

[QUOTE="Relys"][QUOTE="cleotis_max"]

BioShock>ME>CoD4>Halo 3

Honestly.. Halo 3 was a horrible game thats why it's last. I only played the Beta for CoD4 and I hated it, but still it was better then the entire SP campaign in Halo. Mass Effect was mediocre, it was so promising but full of letdown.. The only game out of all 4 of these that I enjoyed from begining to end is BioShock which could explain why im on my 3rd play through... well that and lack of games.

destinhpark

That's your opinion. I, along with a number of other people. Hated Bioshock. All of this is just simple opinion.

....okay? That's fantastic. Thanks for the most pointless post on Gamespot.

Great. It's his opinion. So let him have it without you quoting him and having to "clarify" that it's JUST AN OPINION and Bioshock, according to you, sucks.

Thanks.

Pwned. Thank you.

[QUOTE="destinhpark"][QUOTE="Relys"][QUOTE="cleotis_max"]

BioShock>ME>CoD4>Halo 3

Honestly.. Halo 3 was a horrible game thats why it's last. I only played the Beta for CoD4 and I hated it, but still it was better then the entire SP campaign in Halo. Mass Effect was mediocre, it was so promising but full of letdown.. The only game out of all 4 of these that I enjoyed from begining to end is BioShock which could explain why im on my 3rd play through... well that and lack of games.

cleotis_max

That's your opinion. I, along with a number of other people. Hated Bioshock. All of this is just simple opinion.

....okay? That's fantastic. Thanks for the most pointless post on Gamespot.

Great. It's his opinion. So let him have it without you quoting him and having to "clarify" that it's JUST AN OPINION and Bioshock, according to you, sucks.

Thanks.

Pwned. Thank you.

Anytime.

ME>COD4>Bioshock>Halo 3snackdaddy

Agreed

COD4>Bio>ME>Halo 3

personally i enjoyed all of these games but the most disapointing game had to have been halo 3. sure it looked good but it wasnt as good as or redefining as halo 2 and the rest of the games on this list.

COD4>Bio>ME>Halo 3

personally i enjoyed all of these games but the most disapointing game had to have been halo 3. sure it looked good but it wasnt as good as or redefining as halo 2 and the rest of the games on this list.

masterracer

great minds think alike. :P

[QUOTE="masterracer"]

COD4>Bio>ME>Halo 3

personally i enjoyed all of these games but the most disapointing game had to have been halo 3. sure it looked good but it wasnt as good as or redefining as halo 2 and the rest of the games on this list.

eo12601

great minds think alike. :P

i would have to agree with you there too....

Halo 3>ME>COD4>Bioshock

you're gonne get alot of different answers though, with that said they're all great games there's no question about it

COD4>Bio>ME>Halo 3

personally i enjoyed all of these games but the most disapointing game had to have been halo 3. sure it looked good but it wasnt as good as or redefining as halo 2 and the rest of the games on this list.

masterracer

halo 2 didnt really redefine anything. it just stayed w/ the same formula as halo: combat evolvedand improved upon it, which is pretty much what halo 3 did.

Halo 3 = ME > Bioshock > Cod 4

All great games but cod gotta be on the bottom and the reason is simple i have halo 3 so i dont touch cod mp at all only sp and thats not enough to beat bioshock, ME got the best sp experience on the 360, Halo 3 "finishes the fight" and campaign its second next to ME + Best MP on xbox 360 since H3 got MP ill call it an even with ME

SOF: PAYBACK FTW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

no, really I think - halo>>>>mass effect>>>>cod4>>>>>>>bioshock

All of them are good.