This topic is locked from further discussion.
Play Game in HDTV 720P is Better or 1080i ? and why?BenyaminjBeats me, I'm using S-Video and I can't see a visual different betewn 720p and 1080i since the console upscales 576i to 720p ( albiet I'm on a 32 inch Sharp LCD HDTV ) and what not.
[QUOTE="Benyaminj"]Play Game in HDTV 720P is Better or 1080i ? and why?Kosai_AvonejBeats me, I'm using S-Video and I can't see a visual different betewn 720p and 1080i since the console upscales 576i to 720p ( albiet I'm on a 32 inch Sharp LCD HDTV ) and what not. S-video is not capable of rendering HD, the xbox renders everything in 720p then upscales or downscales according to what you chose in the options blade.
Use your televison's native resolution to everyone who replied in this thread.trickmyster13how do you know your tv's native resolution?
i have a hdtv and its native resolution is 1366 768 i run mine at 720p cos this runs at 60 fps with 1080i it drops to 30fps plus i cant see any difference in quality between the 2
hope this helps
720p is classed as a native resolution for most games, i.e. this is the maximum and optimal setting they are designed to run in, so you are seeing the game as intended.
If you switch to 1080i, your are "forcing" the 360 (or TV) to upscale the image to a higher resolution. The difference is in the "i" - the image signal is interlaced - this means that first, the screen displays half the lines of the image (e.g. line one, line 3, line 5), then it goes back and displays all the lines inbetween these that it missed on the first, but so fast that hopefully you shouldn't notice it. However, this can produce noticeable artefacts on the screen - it can lead to a very slight loss in quality, and in some cases (dependent how fast the TV refreshes the screen and the framerate, and also how cheap a TV it is) fast on-screen movement can produce visible "tearing" or smearing. Now, most folks might not even notice it, but like I said, it depends on the quality of the screen. It's not too different (although not quite as drastic) from watching a normal TV signal on a big LCD screen - it looks pretty crappy because the stanrd 480p signal is being upscaled to match your hi-def ready TV
Now, 1080p, on the other hand, does not interlace, and should be a simple upscaled verson of 720p so should maintain a decent picture. If you TV supports 1080p, then it may be worth trying that for fun and ignoring 1080i altogether.
At the moment, I think only one game (Virtua Tennis? I'm mot sure) is the only one designed to run in 1080p, so you will be best with 720p. Eventually, as more TV's come with native 1080p built in, we might see more game developers building that into their games, That will look awesome!
I have a 50 inch Samsung, and I dont see any difference between 720p and 1080i. They both look equally great. JasonWITrue that..1080i satisfies me greatly.
These threads will never make sense as long as people always assume because a tv says it "supports" both 720p and 1080i that it can actually "display" both when their tv has one native resolution. The best picture is the resolution that matches that.You're oversimplifying this - it's not about resolution - it's about reducing the amount of scaling that has to occur, and removing things that destroy image, such as interlacin Interlaced signal + progressive-scan only set (LCD) = sinfully bad image quality. Your eyes might not be able to see the difference, fine, there is a huge difference to me from 480i to 480p and another huge one from 1080i (which should be called 540i) to 720p. 1080i is a lower image quality than 720p. Period. "real" CRT HDTVs absolutely suck. There is not a single crt-hdtv on the market that doesn't have convergence issues and a low actual display resolution. CRT produces great blacks and colors, but the beam was never meant to trace a narrow rectangle - the technology isn't there, the distortion is. 720p is *the* way to go.
It's more complicated with 1366*768 resolution screens, seeing as that is higher than 720p. Like sometimes downscaling, say an HD movie, from 1080i down to 1366*768 would show more detail on the screen compared to upscaling 720p to 1366*768.
For games though, it's best to just set it to 720p unless you actually have a real CRT 1080i tv, then pick 1080i.
TimothyB
[QUOTE="TimothyB"]These threads will never make sense as long as people always assume because a tv says it "supports" both 720p and 1080i that it can actually "display" both when their tv has one native resolution. The best picture is the resolution that matches that.You're oversimplifying this - it's not about resolution - it's about reducing the amount of scaling that has to occur, and removing things that destroy image, such as interlacin Interlaced signal + progressive-scan only set (LCD) = sinfully bad image quality. Your eyes might not be able to see the difference, fine, there is a huge difference to me from 480i to 480p and another huge one from 1080i (which should be called 540i) to 720p. 1080i is a lower image quality than 720p. Period. "real" CRT HDTVs absolutely suck. There is not a single crt-hdtv on the market that doesn't have convergence issues and a low actual display resolution. CRT produces great blacks and colors, but the beam was never meant to trace a narrow rectangle - the technology isn't there, the distortion is. 720p is *the* way to go.
It's more complicated with 1366*768 resolution screens, seeing as that is higher than 720p. Like sometimes downscaling, say an HD movie, from 1080i down to 1366*768 would show more detail on the screen compared to upscaling 720p to 1366*768.
For games though, it's best to just set it to 720p unless you actually have a real CRT 1080i tv, then pick 1080i.
subrosian
[QUOTE="Benyaminj"]Play Game in HDTV 720P is Better or 1080i ? and why?Kosai_AvonejBeats me, I'm using S-Video and I can't see a visual different betewn 720p and 1080i since the console upscales 576i to 720p ( albiet I'm on a 32 inch Sharp LCD HDTV ) and what not. Far as I know S-video caps out at something like 480i, so the fact that the system upscales does nothing since the cable can't handle it. (I think this is the case, not totally sure). Anyway, to the OP, definitely use the native resolution for your TV if possible. If your TV can handle both, use 720p for the cleanest and crispest picture.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment