"Best XBox360 Game" candidate

Which do you think is more worthy of a nomination and/or award?

Neither one would even be in my top 20. KC_Hokie

I think you guys are missing the point. These are some of the only exclusives the Xbox 360 has gotten this year (I just had a quick look at the 360 section on Gamespot). I usually include PC/360 games when I choose my 360 GotY though, seeing as their both owned by Microsoft, which means most games that would be exclusive to 360 are more then likely going to be made for the PC also, so I'd include Left 4 Dead 2, but out of those 2, ODST simply because I can't stand race simulation games, though I wasn't impressed by ODST.

I think you guys are missing the point. These are some of the only exclusives the Xbox 360 has gotten this year (I just had a quick look at the 360 section on Gamespot). I usually include PC/360 games when I choose my 360 GotY though, seeing as their both owned by Microsoft, which means most games that would be exclusive to 360 are more then likely going to be made for the PC also, so I'd include Left 4 Dead 2, but out of those 2, ODST simply because I can't stand race simulation games, though I wasn't impressed by ODST.

Twin-Blade

I was impressed with Halo 3 ODST and can't wait to get it but it's nowhere near my GOTY.

[QUOTE="Twin-Blade"]

I think you guys are missing the point. These are some of the only exclusives the Xbox 360 has gotten this year (I just had a quick look at the 360 section on Gamespot). I usually include PC/360 games when I choose my 360 GotY though, seeing as their both owned by Microsoft, which means most games that would be exclusive to 360 are more then likely going to be made for the PC also, so I'd include Left 4 Dead 2, but out of those 2, ODST simply because I can't stand race simulation games, though I wasn't impressed by ODST.

KC_Hokie

I should point out I'm not the TC.

Forza 3 Is the Better game but since Im not a big fan of racing games neither of them would be on my top 20 either.

ODST was a good story, I enjoyed it, but I'm still lost on why there isn't a thing like there is in L4D2 where you can go into a lobby room and play the campiagn with some random people. But yeah though, to answer the question, I would go with ODST over Forza, but that's only because I'm not much of a fan of racing video games. I mean, well...I did enjoy the Forza demo, thought the graphics and gameplay were great but I think that it'll just get repetetive after a while.

Halo 3 osdt is the worst game in the halo series.

Since ODST sucked and Forza rocked...

I'll say Forza

If you're talking for just 2009, I'd pick Forza 3 between the two. But overall I'd go with Borderlands. I like it a lot even though the single player isn't as stellar as co-op.

I'd say Pokemon Blue is my favourite

Forza is easily the best exclusive this year, although I haven't had really any time with ODST.

You cant say "Best XBox360 Game" and then just make us choose between two games of totally different genres.

Episodes from Liberty city gets my vote.

You cant say "Best XBox360 Game" and then just make us choose between two games of totally different genres.

Episodes from Liberty city gets my vote.

miless

Foeza 3 hands down