"Unofficial Top 25 Xbox 360 Games of all Time"- RESULTS!!!!

After counting all the votes in the voting thread, I have came up with the results. This was just a survey of about 65 people so don't scream "OMG, this guy is teh bias"!!!!! Anyways, here are the results:

1. Gears of War (380 pts)
2. Call of Duty 4 (355 points)
3. Halo 3 (293 pts)
4. GTA IV (285 pts)
5. Bioshock (230 pts)
6. Mass Effect (194 pts)
7. The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion (173 pts)
8. The Orange Box (146 pts)
9. Assassins Creed (95 pts)
10. Rainbow Six Vegas 2 (64 pts)
11. Rock Band (56 pts/tied for 11th)
12. Forza Motorsport 2 (56 pts/tied for 11th)
13. Guitar Hero 3(53 pts/tied for 13th)
14. BattleField Bad Company (53 pts/tied for 13th)
15. Rainbow Six Vegas (53 pts/tied for 13th)
16. Lost Odyssey (46 pts/Dead Rising should really be #16)
17. Ninja Gaiden 2 (40 pts)
18. Viva Pinata (34 pts)
19. Call of Duty 2 (29 pts)
20. Crackdown (27 pts)
21. Saint Rows (25 pts)
22. Devil May Cry 4 (23 pts/tied for 22nd)
23. PGR4 (23 pts/tied for 22nd)
24. Dirt (19 pts)
25. Lost Planet, NBA 2K8 (17 pts/tie for 25th)

EDIT: I just realized that Dead Rising had 50 pts. I missed it when I was going through the huge list of gsmes. It should really be #16 but I don't feel like making a full edit. I guess this list is now the Top 26 Xbox 360 Games:)

NOTE: To keep the list ordered, I had to list ties in several different places (ex: the tie for 13th).

Thank you to everyone who participated in the survey. As I said before, this isn't 100% accurate (especially near the bottom). Everyone has their own opinion.

Discuss

ahhh NBA 2K8 didnt make the cut ...sux :(solo4321

OH yes it did. It had 17 pts (tie for 25th). I'll add it to the list. Thanks!

[QUOTE="solo4321"]ahhh NBA 2K8 didnt make the cut ...sux :(CrossFire245

OH yes it did. It had 17 pts (tie for 25th). I'll add it to the list. Thanks!

ahhh NBA 2K8 didnt make the cut ...sux :(solo4321

Nor did Skate!!!

The top of the list is almost spot on though. I had Gears #1 and CoD4 #2 so those two picks alone make me happy!

[QUOTE="solo4321"]ahhh NBA 2K8 didnt make the cut ...sux :(nickdastick

Nor did Skate!!!

The top of the list is almost spot on though. I had Gears #1 and CoD4 #2 so those two picks alone make me happy!

Btw, I'm sorry that I didn't include your votes. I was making this thread and never looked back at the voting one.

[QUOTE="nickdastick"]

[QUOTE="solo4321"]ahhh NBA 2K8 didnt make the cut ...sux :(CrossFire245

Nor did Skate!!!

The top of the list is almost spot on though. I had Gears #1 and CoD4 #2 so those two picks alone make me happy!

Btw, I'm sorry that I didn't include your votes. I was making this thread and never looked back at the voting one.

It's all good. I lost track of time. I had a half an hour to finish it but I do chat tech support for dell computers and this one person had an issue that was very involving so I didn't even get back to the list until after the time was passed. I just posted it before I realized it was 24 mins after the deadline.

And 1 more thing I had not noticed before. Mass Effect over Oblivion? That's very surprising because if you set up a thread right now comparing the two, the vote would overwhelmingly favor Oblivion. When doing one of these greatest of all time voting, it is always interesting to see the prevelance of the what-have-you-done-for-me-lately attitude or ignorance of all events prior to the last 12 months. But then again it is easy to forget about the games when they are not so fresh in your mind.roc321

I think the reason Mass Effect got put up there above Oblivion is because Mass Effect appealed to more people so more people had it on their list. I had it on mine but not Oblivion because there were a lot of things I HATED about Oblivion's gameplay. I'm not a big RPG player but Mass Effect had me hooked from the start. So I don't think it's really because it's more fresh in people's minds, I just think it appealed to more people and was more accessable.

[QUOTE="roc321"]And 1 more thing I had not noticed before. Mass Effect over Oblivion? That's very surprising because if you set up a thread right now comparing the two, the vote would overwhelmingly favor Oblivion. When doing one of these greatest of all time voting, it is always interesting to see the prevelance of the what-have-you-done-for-me-lately attitude or ignorance of all events prior to the last 12 months. But then again it is easy to forget about the games when they are not so fresh in your mind.nickdastick

I think the reason Mass Effect got put up there above Oblivion is because Mass Effect appealed to more people so more people had it on their list. I had it on mine but not Oblivion because there were a lot of things I HATED about Oblivion's gameplay. I'm not a big RPG player but Mass Effect had me hooked from the start. So I don't think it's really because it's more fresh in people's minds, I just think it appealed to more people and was more accessable.

Nice list.

Even though i would have Halo 3 and Gears Of War at a tie for 1st place!!

Lost Odyssey is below Bioshock? this... this is madness!bulletsword

You do realize that Bioshock was given game of the year awards and things like that right? No offense, but Lost Odyssey doesn't hold a candle to Bioshock at least with the majority.

[QUOTE="bulletsword"]Lost Odyssey is below Bioshock? this... this is madness!nickdastick

You do realize that Bioshock was given game of the year awards and things like that right? No offense, but Lost Odyssey doesn't hold a candle to Bioshock at least with the majority.

Yeah, I own both and I absolutely agree. Lost Odyssey doesn't come even close to Bioshock. Good list by the way. Thanks TS.

[QUOTE="nickdastick"]

[QUOTE="bulletsword"]Lost Odyssey is below Bioshock? this... this is madness!Jaforbe

You do realize that Bioshock was given game of the year awards and things like that right? No offense, but Lost Odyssey doesn't hold a candle to Bioshock at least with the majority.

Yeah, I own both and I absolutely agree. Lost Odyssey doesn't come even close to Bioshock. Good list by the way. Thanks TS.

I guess i'm just different but to me Lost odyssey was just truly epic. I'm just a jrpg kinda guy though so to me it's my favorite game in years. Can't wait for all of the other rpgs coming out this year.

[QUOTE="Jaforbe"][QUOTE="nickdastick"]

[QUOTE="bulletsword"]Lost Odyssey is below Bioshock? this... this is madness!craigalan23

You do realize that Bioshock was given game of the year awards and things like that right? No offense, but Lost Odyssey doesn't hold a candle to Bioshock at least with the majority.

Yeah, I own both and I absolutely agree. Lost Odyssey doesn't come even close to Bioshock. Good list by the way. Thanks TS.

I guess i'm just different but to me Lost odyssey was just truly epic. I'm just a jrpg kinda guy though so to me it's my favorite game in years. Can't wait for all of the other rpgs coming out this year.

Yeah, Lost Odyssey was awesome. I think I would have personaly liked it even more but I was unable to finish it. It was the first jrpg i'd bought in years and my attention span changed quite a bit since I was younger.

[QUOTE="craigalan23"][QUOTE="Jaforbe"][QUOTE="nickdastick"]

[QUOTE="bulletsword"]Lost Odyssey is below Bioshock? this... this is madness!Jaforbe

You do realize that Bioshock was given game of the year awards and things like that right? No offense, but Lost Odyssey doesn't hold a candle to Bioshock at least with the majority.

Yeah, I own both and I absolutely agree. Lost Odyssey doesn't come even close to Bioshock. Good list by the way. Thanks TS.

I guess i'm just different but to me Lost odyssey was just truly epic. I'm just a jrpg kinda guy though so to me it's my favorite game in years. Can't wait for all of the other rpgs coming out this year.

Yeah, Lost Odyssey was awesome. I think I would have personaly liked it even more but I was unable to finish it. It was the first jrpg i'd bought in years and my attention span changed quite a bit since I was younger.

Yeah my attention span isn't as great and i stopped playing for alittle bit. I needed a break from playing non-stop strategy games and just wanted mindless violence. I'm at the beginining of disc 4 and man i just love everything about it and it brought back great childhood memories or FFX and others.

[QUOTE="bulletsword"]Lost Odyssey is below Bioshock? this... this is madness!nickdastick

You do realize that Bioshock was given game of the year awards and things like that right? No offense, but Lost Odyssey doesn't hold a candle to Bioshock at least with the majority.

Yea, I actually thought Bioshock deserved better.

NO NHL 08 mwhat is wrong with you people! Glad to see BF:BC in 13th place after only being out for a couple weeks.torontomapleafs

Yea we got robbed, can't wait for 09.

NO NHL 08 mwhat is wrong with you people! Glad to see BF:BC in 13th place after only being out for a couple weeks.torontomapleafs

I totally agree! Sports games get the shaft though usually because they aren't as popular overall like the other gametypes. I think NHL 08 should have been on there for sure as well as Skate. Those are two amazingly good games!

oblivion belongs on the TOP. if it had online then we would have lost our livesfootballa27

Lol yup.

NO NHL 08 mwhat is wrong with you people! Glad to see BF:BC in 13th place after only being out for a couple weeks.torontomapleafs

BF:BC actually started out really strong, but got weaker. However, it still managed to get into the tie for 13th.