Red Dead Redemption or Sleeping Dogs?

Which one in your opinion ? 

RDR is one of the best games this generation. Gotta give it to RDR.

yeah i used to own it and regrettably got rid of it a while back was thinking of getting it again.

RDR by a country mile.

Sleeping Dogs is good but it doesn't even come close to Red Dead Redemption. 

RDR by a country mile.

Ilovegames1992

So I guess that I am the only one that thinks that Sleeping Dogs is the better of the two games.

I own and played both games. I got bored with Red Dead Redemption about halfway through, but Sleeping Dogs I played all the way through and then some. I think RDR was original and different compared to anything else out there, but that is all it had going for it so it is a good game just boring. Sleeping Dogs is better in every way with alot more to do that keeps you interested throughout the entire game, and the dlc is really cool compared to RDR which was just as boring as the the game itself.

So I guess that I am the only one that thinks that Sleeping Dogs is the better of the two games.

I own and played both games. I got bored with Red Dead Redemption about halfway through, but Sleeping Dogs I played all the way through and then some. I think RDR was original and different compared to anything else out there, but that is all it had going for it so it is a good game just boring. Sleeping Dogs is better in every way with alot more to do that keeps you interested throughout the entire game, and the dlc is really cool compared to RDR which was just as boring as the the game itself.

 

ghstbstr

I got bored with red dead as well. Eventually, everything began to feel like a chore, and the story didn't develope as well as I'd hope. You just end up doing more and more fetch quests for people, while the climax was postponed. It felt like they couldnt think of anymore story to write, but they had to keep the length up, so they put in filler missions and stuck in uninteresting characters to do those missions with.

The game wasnt bad, but it wasnt as good as I thought itd be. I never played sleeping dogs, but it may be the better choice in the end.

I would say Sleeping Dogs. The game is just funner and more things to do. Controls are a lot tighter and more fluid than RDR too. RDR is still a good game tho, I just liked Sleeping Dogs better.

RDR

RDR is one of the best video games ever made...go with that one.

Red Dead for sure if you've never played it. Sleeping Dogs is a fantastic game too, but Red Dead is an absolute masterpiece.

Sleeping Dogs is no doubt a solid, enjoyable game, but Red Dead Redemption is a once in a generation type game. Hands down one of the best games I've ever played.

Red Dead Redemption, man. Sleeping dogs is awesome, but Red Dead Redemption is the best game of this generation.

RDR is one of the best games this generation. Gotta give it to RDR.

Patrickbrown56

RDR all the way.

Red Dead Redemption is an extremely unique experience.

RDR!

I'm giving RDR a try, because all I ever here in the forums is RDR is so awesome!  It's almost like the gaming world has been brainwashed...I will know soon enough.

I'm giving RDR a try, because all I ever here in the forums is RDR is so awesome!  It's almost like the gaming world has been brainwashed...I will know soon enough.

leonus3d

Ok, so I must be brain washed too...I bought the game and haven't stopped playing it. RDR immediately sucked me into its world and I hate leaving it. Enough of this talk gotta play RDR.

RDR is one of the best games this gen.

RDR is one of the best games Rockstar ever made.

Go. Get. It. NOW!

RDR was the best game i ever played, Sleeping Dogs felt like a generic sandbox game with combat stolen from arkham asylum..

neither