Both. Most of my favorites are hybrids of the two genres.
RPGs are ultimately more fun, but there's some qualifications there. Mainly, I just don't care for JRPGs anymore. My main interest in rpgs is more along the lines of what I loved about the pen and paper RPGs. You created the character and were able to make choices that shaped what your character was about and how they behaved. Which is why I'm perfectly fine with an open world like in Morrowind with barely any hint of a story to get in the way.
JRPGs tend to be too rigid and too linear for my taste. With the characters, motives, actions during cutscenes all set, it's hardly role-playing in the sense of the word someone would use when generating their own character. Ideally, there should be at least some choice there. I don't mind a well written character, and some actions that the player has no control over, as long as there's some effect of player choice. Deus Ex, KOTOR, and Mass Effect are good examples of that.
Shooters are generally a safer bet. If it's bad, it's usually still at least somewhat tolerable. Though, I don't like the tendency to create small set pieces where you fight over a small courtyard while enemies constantly spawn before moving onto the next area and repeating.
Log in to comment