[spoiler] Did you like the ending in Red Dead Redemption???

The ending for me was undoubtedly good and fitting, but I didn't really want it to end the way it did . . . I would've liked it better if the actual ending of the game was when you finally met your family after you killed Dutch then just resumed to free roam . . .

The ending?

Or the ending after the ending?

I loved RDR, one of the best games I've ever played.

Eh I enjoyed it, it wasn't the best but it was fitting and a pretty epic way to go.

The ending?

Or the ending after the ending?

I loved RDR, one of the best games I've ever played.

ZombieKiller7

What do you mean, I'm talking about the ending where John got shot by soldiers and died then 3 years later Abigail died as well and now I resume free roam using Jack . . . Is there another ending after this???

I liked the ending, one of my favorites all time.

Red Dead Redemption is my favorite game this gen and the ending DOES seem fitting, but at first I was like... Sh!t Marston!!!! I mean he was massacred.... Then when you avenge John's death it ends well...

[QUOTE="ZombieKiller7"]

The ending?

Or the ending after the ending?

I loved RDR, one of the best games I've ever played.

JeanAlex22

What do you mean, I'm talking about the ending where John got shot by soldiers and died then 3 years later Abigail died as well and now I resume free roam using Jack . . . Is there another ending after this???

Yes, after you gain control of Jack there is another objective that allows you to finish what Marston started.

Speaking of the ending, does anyone know what song was played at the end? Not the credits one, but while you ride home for the first time. Near the end of the game.

[QUOTE="ZombieKiller7"]

The ending?

Or the ending after the ending?

I loved RDR, one of the best games I've ever played.

JeanAlex22

What do you mean, I'm talking about the ending where John got shot by soldiers and died then 3 years later Abigail died as well and now I resume free roam using Jack . . . Is there another ending after this???

I loved the ending. Having John die was really the only fitting ending for the game, tragic though it was. Although I don't think I would have enjoyed it nearly as much if they hadn't put in the revenge sidequest after it.

Honestly? I didn't really care for it. Nothing against anyone that did, it was a great story. I don't know I guess I'm one of those people I spend so much time invested in the character and the story that I just hate seeing them killed off.

The ending was extremey effective, yes. But afterwards I was like "Dang it, I don't want to play as his son." Haha doesn't make sense, but yeah :) I guess overall I liked it.

I loved it. The game drew me in and the ending was like a movie. I still didn't finish the game fully. I just don't want it to end lol.

I loved and hated the ending. Therefore I loved it. I didn't want John to die. I felt like I knew him, like we bonded on his journey. From the first mission getting shot, to riding home to his family after everything right up until the moment you knew what was going to happen. He just felt like a part of you. His tragic end really changed the way games do things. It felt honest.

Seemed a fitting end, especially when Jack avenges his father, but I hate Jack because he's a panzy. John was a better, more developed character.MaxPayneKillers

Absolutely. RDD's ending is one of the best that I've ever seen in a game. The build-up to it was masterfully done. After John gets his "life" back, I bascially thought the game was over, but what happenend when the "law" came for him? Man, that was a shock.

The actual ending of it just blew me away. The credits started rolling and I was just like... "Wow". Basically speechless. So yeah, extremely good ending.

The ending?

Or the ending after the ending?

I loved RDR, one of the best games I've ever played.

ZombieKiller7

This. And both were good.

Well it might sound like.... too much but i played this game last summer and till this day it feels like i lost someone i knew. Good memories though. So the ending worked..

This thread makes me want to complete RDR for the third time.

I didn't like the ending, or in a sense...I didn't like the build up to the ending. After you reunite with your family you have to play a bunch of missions with John Marston's family. It just felt like obvious characters development and seemed really forced. It also doesn't help that the missions that you play with the family are very very boring.

NO! i hated playing as john's son he is a little b**** compared to john marston.

HELL NO. they killed my dude!!! BUT he went out like a trooper

hopefully rockstar does know better and have a 2 in the works

*********************SPOILERS************************

By the time John met his untimely death, I was started to get a bit bored with the game. It seemed to have dragged on forever and I was ready for it to end. That being said, the game was pretty "epic" and I can't deny the high production values it has. I thought John's death was a fitting end, considering all he went through and the people he was working for the whole time. I wasn't a huge fan of having to play as Jack for a little while afterwards, but I thought it was neat nevertheless that you got revenge on the man responsible for your father's murder. It was definitely a solid ending that made me a bit shocked after having been tired of the game beforehand.

Mass Effect 3s ending actually reminded me of RDRs ending

You spend the entire game trying to escape your past, trying to put things right & in the end..... you die.

In ME3s ending you spend the entire game fighting the reapers, trying to save the galaxy & in the end........ you guessed it.

Funny how people were so harsh on ME3 for not having a happy ending but everybody seems to be fine with RDR.

I personally like sad ending more. RDR ending was unique, the same way ME3s ending was. They didnt copp out for some lame happy ending, they really made you feel by having the charcater die at the end no matter what you do. Its realistic, it wasnt predictable.

You care for people more after their death than you do when they're alive.

Yes I loved it even though people spoiled it for me.

Its easily one of, if not THE best ending in games. Its shocking but not entirely hard to see coming with subtle hints given throughout, and when the "true" second ending happens you feel satisfied. The game and its epic journey concluded, and though Marston is dead his legacy lives on, despite his son now taking up the lifestyle he sought to protect him from.

No. Too melancholy for my tastes.Maor-Teo

John got his, so did Edgar Ross, as will we all.

Poiler (just in case):

Perfect ending for an outstanding game.

I didn't like the idea of John dying, but it was fitting, climating and all around great.

Also, taking revenge with his son made me feel great, emptied my gun on the bastard ^^

I liked the ending, one of my favorites all time.

Blueresident87