The Darkness or Mass Effect?

I took advantage of an Amazon sale where you buy Bioshock and get The Darkness free, but my question is should I keep The Darkness or should I exchange it for something else? I just got a 360 and the only games I have are R6: Vegas, Fight Night, NBA 2K8, Call Of Duty 4, and now BioShock and The Darkness. I have too many shooters. Which game should I trade it in for? I'm leaning towards Mass Effect cause I hear it's IMMENSE and will keep me busy for hours.

Also, do you think places like Wal-Mart and Target will exchange the game for another one if it's still in the original shrink wrap and has never been opened?

i would get Mass Effect over the darkness, but the darkness is and older game so idk how much you will get for itApplesAndCarmel

Mass Effect. Although try out The Darkness demo, its brilliant. Great atmosphere and stuff, but it seems like it may get repetetive, nevertheless, seems like a great game, but mass effect is just amazing.

Wouldn't Target or Wal-Mart take it for exchange straight up since it's unopened and sealed in the original shrinkwrap? I can just say it was given to me as a gift but I already had it and wanted to exchange it for something else.

Mass Effec tis the better game, but i own them both and i personally think they botha re two of the better singleplayer games this year.

But Mass effect is definatly ythe better game

Wouldn't Target or Wal-Mart take it for exchange straight up since it's unopened and sealed in the original shrinkwrap? I can just say it was given to me as a gift but I already had it and wanted to exchange it for something else.

SRome82

I may be incorrect, but I think Walmart will give you the current retail value. So, The Darkness may be less than $60.

After checking Walmart.com, it looks to be a $3 difference. I would go with Mass Effect.

Mass Effect easily the Darkness is ok but can be finished in a day or two of casual playing.(I rented it and beat it)

Now Mass Effect is just the best single player experience IMO since Legend of zelda orcina of time. And the darknesses multi

doesnt work.

Comparing Mass Effect to the The Darkness is like comparing the Atlantic ocean to a mud puddle.