What are the most underrated/overrated games on the 360?

Mine, personally, are:

Underrated

-Lost Odyssey(7.5? Is that a joke?)

-Battlefield 2: Modern Combat(Definately an 8-8.5)

-Far Cry: Instincts Predator

-Lost Planet: Extreme Condition(9.0, hands down)

Overrated

-Turok(Seemed more like a 6.0)

-GRAW 1/2

-CoD 4(Repetitive, deserves an 8.0-8.5)

COD4 deserves atleast a 9.0.

Underrated would be Condemned, i see it as a ground-breaking game.

These some of the 51 Xbox360 games that I have. So for the games that I considered to be overrated doesn't mean that I do not like them as I do not like them as much as everyone else does, and the games that I considered to be underrated so be rated alot higher then they are.

Overrated Xbox360 games are:
BioShock
Gears of War
Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six Vegas

Underrated Xbox360 games are:
Battlestations: Midway
BlackSite: Area 51
Blazing Angels: Squadrons of WWII
Blazing Angels 2: Secret Missions of WWII
Call of Duty 3
The Darkness
Kane & Lynch: Dead Men
Lost Planet: Extreme Condition
Medal of Honor: Airborne
Prey
Star Trek: Legacy
TimeShift
Transformers: The Game
Turok

Underated: Lost Odyssey, The Darkness and maybe Kameo and PGR4

Overated: Assassins Creed, Oblivion, Rainbow Six: Vegas

yes Kane and Lynch was under-rated... despite its mechanical flaws, it was still an pretty neat game, neat enough for me to play through the whole thing in one day.

and of course Assassins Creed. Over-Rated

assassins creed was underrated

nba 2k8 was underrated

cod4 was overrated

I think Crackdown doesn't get nearly as much respect as it deserves.

Halo 3 is over rated. It is a fun game and has some pretty great mp, but it's not as good as ppl say.

underated

PGr4, command and conquere tiberium wars, kameo, Lost Oddessey, Rainbow six vegas, skate, star wars lego, Viva Pinata, and if were going by critical appraise Guitar Hero 3, i don't know how it got scored lower then rockband i'd say at least there about equal.

COD4 , half life 2 portion of orange box only (the rest is amazing in my opinion), burnout paradise, forza 2

Underrated
Eternal Sonata. Deserved a 9 in my opinion. great game and by far my favorite game for the 360 right now.
Marvel: Ultimate Alliance. Also deserves a 9. I loved this and i'm hyped up for the next game.

Overrated
Bioshock. 8.0 is where it's at for me. I'd play Halo 3 any day over this. I hate how i pretty much gave in to the hype for this one. i have the PC version btw.
Halo 3. I'd call it 8.5/10, but at least it's pretty good.

Overrated - Halo 3 and Assassin's Creed

Underrated - Condemned

Overrated- Freakin Halo 3, maybe 8.0 to 8.3 ish..

Underrated- BioShock, awesome game, i give it 9.5 for what it is...

Overrated - Halo 3, It is a great game but I was a little disappointed by the single player

Underrated - Shadowrun, I know everyone else seems to hate it but it is one of my favorites

Underated: Lost Odyssey

Overated: Gears of War

Overall most overrated game across all platforms in general is COD4, mind you i have the game and while its excellent its also way too overhyped this game just reminds me of when i played Counter Strike.

Couple underrated games would probably be: Darkness, ace combat and pgr4

Underrated: Lost Odyssey, Mass Effect, The Darkness

Overrated: Assassin's Creed, Gears of War

underrated - just cause and far cry

overrated - perfect dark zero and halo 3

Overrated=halo 3 Call of duty4

Underrated=Blue Dragon Lost Odyssey

Overrated:

• CoD4
• Turok
• GRAW

Underrated:

• Condemned
• Crackdown
• Jericho

Underrated - Condemned : Criminal Origins, Call of Duty 3.

Overrated - Gears of War, BioShock.

Overrated:

1. COD4:its fun and all with addictive multiplayer but in all honsty it is just a well put together fps with little to no innovation and the maps aren't too great and too small IMO

2.Assassins Creed: this game was really fun for like five miutes and then the novelty wore off and i just kept exploring to find more of its flaws and mess around

3.The Darkness: this game is always called underrated but i call it an overrated underrated game if theere was ever such a thing. My reasoning is that for me the autoaim and overall mechanics of the game were not for me and relaly pissed me off. However i did love the cutscenes.

The Darkness and Saints Row are extremely underrated

Hour of Victory is extremely overrated. I dont know what it got, like a 2 or 3, and even that is way too high

i really try to use the demos available for download as it is too expensive to rent unless you do gamefly or something. so my overrated games are based on the demos mostly.

overrated

all halo multiplayer, just gets old fast to me but single player is amazing

mass effect only because of the slow rpg aspect, the fights are great i should have rented instead of buying this one

fear single player was plain scary but multi i thought sucked

prey story was cool but just didnt deliver and multi was terrible

underappreciated

crackdown - by far the most underated game out there, i spent hours looking for orbs, remember that noise!?!?!

assasins creed - very very good game, open world but has structure and i could look for flags all day

kameo - mario for adults, all i can say loved it

condemned - made me poop in my pants

saints row - just plain fun and tons to do

stranglehold - i never tried multi because i rentted it to beat it, but great fun

hitman blood money - when will the next one come out? very different missions, fun

for me overrated would have to be lost planet....just not as much fun..the single player was ok but not outstandin and the multiplayer was kinda weak

underrated for me has to be lost odyssey so far....it is a very good deep game so far and i like it alot

Underrated: Shadowrun (no seriously, buy it, its $20 or less), Crackdown (people, myself included, just bought it for the Halo 3 beta but often overlook the fact that its a really cool game), Earth Defense Force 2017 (its so ridiculously bad that its good) maybe Dead Rising to some extent (I really feel like it didn't get enough credit for how insanely fun it was)

I don't think any games can count as overrated, lots of people think games are overrated that other people love but, for me, I would say Forza 2, Guitar hero 3 and the Half Life series

Underrated Shadowrun, condemmed, viva pinata

Overrated= GRAW 1 and 2, LOst planet, COD3

Underrated: Kane and Lynch, PGR 4, Overlord, DMC4(deserved a 9) and Virtua Fighter 5 Online

Overated: Perfect dark Zero, Dead Rising, Forza 2

Underated:Call of Duty 3 - Everyone bags on it when I think that while not Call of Duty 2, is still very good. Undertow - One of the best arcade games imo, but everyone seems to hate it :? Need For Speed: Carbon - This game was pure awesome, yet it only got relatively acceptable scores.

Overated: Bioshock - Boring as hell. The Darkness - Awesome story couldn't save the horrid gunplay. Devil May Cry 4 - I have this game, and maybe it's because I had played Ninja Gaiden: Sigma before playing this, but while the combat was good, the enemies were repeated far too often, there was too much backtracking, the puzzles were boring, and the environments were confusing and boring as well... 7.0 at best :( Dead Rising - A fun romp at heart marred by an awful mission and save system that can cause you to have to restart the ENTIRE game.

Underrated: Eternal Sonata, Naruto Rise of a Ninja, Condemned

Overrated: Halo 3, Gears of War, Bio Shock

Underrated - Shadowrun, Crackdown, the Darkness

Overrated - Gears of War

For me:

Underrated: Lego Star Wars 2 , The Godfather

Overrated: NHL 08

underrated=assassins creed

overrated=HALO HALO HALO HALO

Overrated: HALO 3

Underrated: Crackdown

Timeshift

Stranglehold

Lost Odyssey and Mass Effect are both underated. Is it just me or does Gayspot just hate RPG's.

Graw 1 was **** awesome at the time. Part 2 was the same **** different day just like Vegas 2 will be.

COD Deserves a 9 because of the C130 mission.

Battlestations Midway was a pritty underated game.

Assasins Creed is the most overated.

Most Underrated: Prey and Crackdown

Most Overrated: Halo 3 and Assassins Creed