What game will win GOTY???

Which game will win Game of the Year (GOTY)

1. Gears of War 2

2. Left 4 Dead

3. Fallout 3

4. Metal Gear Solid 4

5. Dead Space

6. Little Big Planet

Pres GotY:

1. GTA IV

2. Super Smash Bros. Brawl

3. Gears of War 2

4. Resistance 2

5. Tie: Left 4 Dead/Metal Gear Solid 4

Fan GotY:

1. Super Smash Bros. Brawl

2. GTA IV

3. Gears of War 2

4. Metal Gear Solid 4

5. LittleBigPlanet

My GotY:

1. Super Smash Bros. Brawl

2. SoulCalibur IV

3. Losy Odyssey

4. Dance Dance Revolution Universe

5. Dance Dance Revolution: Hottest Party 2

Fall Out 3.

But seriously.... why Left 4 Dead? It's got 2004 computer graphics and the story mode is 2 hours long... GOTY!! 

probably mgs4. Havent played it, but ive only heard good things.

other than that id say Fallout 3. 

Fall Out 3.

 

But seriously.... why Left 4 Dead? It's got 2004 computer graphics and the story mode is 2 hours long... GOTY!! 

DPhunkT

Because it has amazing co-op? It's loads of fun. There's lots of reasons. Also the story mode is 5 hours on normal and 10 on expert if you can even beat it. I love how people say graphics should create GOTY. Let me guess Assassins creed was your GOTY last year?

I would vote for Fallout 3 or LBP. GTA IV was great but I dont think it can compare with Fallout 3 or LBP. Gears of War 2 if fun but it looks and plays a lot like the first Gears and the multiplayer isn't what a lot of people expected so I doubt it has a chance.

[QUOTE="DPhunkT"]

Fall Out 3.

 

But seriously.... why Left 4 Dead? It's got 2004 computer graphics and the story mode is 2 hours long... GOTY!! 

craigalan23

Because it has amazing co-op? It's loads of fun. There's lots of reasons. Also the story mode is 5 hours on normal and 10 on expert if you can even beat it. I love how people say graphics should create GOTY. Let me guess Assassins creed was your GOTY last year?

[QUOTE="DPhunkT"]

Fall Out 3.

 

But seriously.... why Left 4 Dead? It's got 2004 computer graphics and the story mode is 2 hours long... GOTY!! 

craigalan23

Because it has amazing co-op? It's loads of fun. There's lots of reasons. Also the story mode is 5 hours on normal and 10 on expert if you can even beat it. I love how people say graphics should create GOTY. Let me guess Assassins creed was your GOTY last year?

Overall = Fallout 3

360 = Fallout 3

PS3 = MGS 4

[QUOTE="craigalan23"][QUOTE="DPhunkT"]

Fall Out 3.

 

But seriously.... why Left 4 Dead? It's got 2004 computer graphics and the story mode is 2 hours long... GOTY!! 

DPhunkT

Because it has amazing co-op? It's loads of fun. There's lots of reasons. Also the story mode is 5 hours on normal and 10 on expert if you can even beat it. I love how people say graphics should create GOTY. Let me guess Assassins creed was your GOTY last year?

Which game will win Game of the Year (GOTY)

1. Gears of War 2

2. Left 4 Dead

3. Fallout 3

4. Metal Gear Solid 4

5. Dead Space

6. Little Big Planet

Which game will win Game of the Year (GOTY)

 

1. Gears of War 2

2. Left 4 Dead

3. Fallout 3

4. Metal Gear Solid 4

5. Dead Space

6. Little Big Planet

grantbyce

None of the above.. GTA 4 will..

Pres GotY:

1. GTA IV

2. Super Smash Bros. Brawl

3. Gears of War 2

4. Resistance 2

5. Tie: Left 4 Dead/Metal Gear Solid 4

Fan GotY:

1. Super Smash Bros. Brawl

2. GTA IV

3. Gears of War 2

4. Metal Gear Solid 4

5. LittleBigPlanet

My GotY:

1. Super Smash Bros. Brawl

2. SoulCalibur IV

3. Losy Odyssey

4. Dance Dance Revolution Universe

5. Dance Dance Revolution: Hottest Party 2

GamerJM

I pray you are  female with Dance Dance Revolution on your list..

GTA4 everyone seemed to love it.. except us. or mgs4. but mgs4 is boring imo, and after you beat it, you can't do a lot with it.

my goty 

would be gears of war 2, i don't have a 360 but that game is awesome, no other exclusive was as much fun as it this year.

Metal Gear Solid 4 deserves it the most.

Maybe Fallout 3, from what I've heard.

Banjo Kazooie Nutz and Bolts > All

on the candidates that ive played and i rly think it deserve it is:

gear of war 2

but!, GTA4 and MGS4 r nothing else than good, that i ve heard...so far

mine would be fallout 3 or r6v2(which i thought was very underrated).but im positive itll be gta 4 since it has the highest metacritic score since Ocorina of Time.and i imagine that game sites like to make the game multiplatform to keep the fanboys from going rabid that their console does(or doesnt)have the game.