what game would you pick Eternal Sonata or the orange for the month October?

I'm on the a tight budget for a little while so i'm onlygetting one game a month. August bioshock, sept. halo 3 and oct??? I figure its between eternal sonata and the orange box. I havent play a good rpg be in a long time butthe orange boshas alot of values for the buck. Im playing through halo 3 so there might not be another roomfor ashooter in library till left 4 dead. What do you guys think?

I would get Orange Box, if you're in a tight budget it may be the best offer.

I would certainly get GRAW 2 though, :) It's amazing graphics, sweet single-player and spectacular multiplayer, totally kills me. I love it.

both are pure crap lmao, get fifa 08! or guitar hero 3 or PGR4!!bigboy2092

I would get OB i did not like ES graphic style or what not.

both are pure crap lmao, get fifa 08! or guitar hero 3 or PGR4!!bigboy2092

:|

Anyways, go with HL2: Orange Box. Eternal Sonata is a great game, but HL2 is better.

....hellgate london on pc....

[QUOTE="bigboy2092"]both are pure crap lmao, get fifa 08! or guitar hero 3 or PGR4!!BioShockOwnz

:|

Anyways, go with HL2: Orange Box. Eternal Sonata is a great game, but HL2 is better.

orange box.

cause im getting eternal sonata on the ps3 early next year.

a little bit mroe serious now...eternal sonata 360. i have enough shooters as is.

Both are best in class through October. I LOVE Eternal Sonata, but I can't pick it over the best fps of the modern era. Trade in Halo 3 and get both.

I'm getting the Orage Box the day it comes outo_sausage

ditto

I would say get both of them!

Eternal Sonata is the best RPG of the year and best on the 360 so far.

While Orange Box is a great value with alot of singleplayer action and Team Fortress 2 which could be the best online shooter this year.

both are pure crap lmao, get fifa 08! or guitar hero 3 or PGR4!!bigboy2092

Lol... Are you serious?

i rented eternal sonata and its very good, but i was able to beat it in like 2 days, but then again i played a ton non-stop.

i'd rent eternal sonata and then buy orange box.

both are pure crap lmao, get fifa 08! or guitar hero 3 or PGR4!!bigboy2092

crap is in the eye of the beholder. the 3 games you just mentioned are the opposite of fun, IMO.

I bought Eternal Sonata and the name says it all. Unless you like really boring mellow drama get the orange box or you might end up in eternal sleep.CorporateHammer

He is completely right, I'm like 12 hours into it and it's unfortunately boring and slow, I like the idea of Chopin but you can't go wrong with Half Life 2.