Which of these 360 games should I get?

Next month getting Rock Band 2 & Gears of War 2 after that...currently own RB1, Halo 3, and CoD4.

I have a $20, and these are the games that I found for that price (used, duh :P):

Gears of War 1 (maybe, I've heard it's fun but is 2 months enough to enjoy a game before it's sequel comes out?)

Orange Box (probably not because I want it for TF2, and I heard it's not that populated online)

Mass Effect (meh, not so sure...kinda a multiplayer guy)

BioShock (same as above)

What do you think?

The Orange Box. Why? Because it is 5 games in 1. Also it has Portal...

P.S. The cake is a lie

You'll enjoy Gears of War the most, because the multiplayer is great and it offers you a solid campaign.

Out of your list though, my personal favorite game is Bio Shock

hummer700

How long is BioShock? (gameplay wise)

Mass Effect, but sounds like you may enjoy Gears better.fenwickhotmail

Is Mass Effect reallllllyyyy long? I'm scared I'd get bored like halfway through :\

GOW: has alot of people playing is 4th played on the 360, and it has co up wich is my fabotite, but achivements are time consuming.

Orange box: the game has very little playing it, team fostres sucks.

mass effect: Never played but if you enjoy RPG'S, go for it, althoght the achivements are stupid, and is going to take you over 40 hours to passed it, considering you dont get lost.

BioShock: after playing cod4 and halo 3 before this game, bioshock seems bad if you like that typed of styled shooters go for it but i heard it has no replay value, so its beter as a rent considering it has no online.

GOW: has alot of people playing is 4th played on the 360, and it has co up wich is my fabotite, but achivements are time consuming.

Orange box: the game has very little playing it, team fostres sucks.

mass effect: Never played but if you enjoy RPG'S, go for it, althoght the achivements are stupid, and is going to take you over 40 hours to passed it, considering you dont get lost.

BioShock: after playing cod4 and halo 3 before this game, bioshock seems bad if you like that typed of styled shooters go for it but i heard it has no replay value, so its beter as a rent considering it has no online.

Hmm, it might be better as a rent. But you also have to remember that GoW2 is coming out soon, after that GoW1 is obsolete (maybe I'll sell it for some GameStop credit)..

But yeah, I guess it would be smart to rent BioShock, I mean it will only probably take me a couple days to beat it, right?

Mass Effect I'm not really into, too long for me.

I'm guessing you're rooting for Gears though?

Get Gears of War.