![](https://www.gamespot.com/a/uploads/scale_tiny/box/5/2/3/0/53533-125230.jpg)
Silent Hunter 5: Battle of the Atlantic Review
Silent Hunter 5 has promise, but this buggy and unstable game needs to be sent back to the drydock for some serious refitting.
This review has been revised in December 2011. The reason is because Silent Hunter 5 has been updated since its release, and those updtaes have addressed some of the original problems with the game, including the removal... Read Full Review
3 of 3 users found the following review helpfulI mean why would company took out all great things about previous SH games and gave us All flash, no substance broken game? I thought that company that never dissapointed before is just gonna make this game better and be... Read Full Review
17 of 17 users found the following review helpfulThe box has been gathering dust on my shelf since 2010, but I decided to give it another go. It's nice to see that the DRM is dead after the patches. However, as seen in my old review, this wasn't the real problem with t... Read Full Review
3 of 5 users found the following review helpfulThis review has been revised in December 2011. The reason is because Silent Hunter 5 has been updated since its release, and those updtaes have addressed some of the original problems with the game, including the removal... Read Full Review
3 of 3 users found the following review helpfulI'm totally sure, no one at ubi soft tried to play this game before selling it. This days it's very hard to start a game and immediately notice bugs, only UBI brings you this joy. The bugs are infinite and everywhe... Read Full Review
0 of 0 users found the following review helpfulEnough reviewers have already touched on the DRM so I wont go no where near that epic failure. As far as the game goes in its retail released state, its still in a open beta state. Im not sure what Ubisoft was thinking ... Read Full Review
0 of 0 users found the following review helpfulI bought this game thinking it couldn't be too different from the other 4 that I happen to be a huge fan of. Wow was I wrong. They turned it into some sort of half baked RPG that takes place in first person. I hate this ... Read Full Review
2 of 2 users found the following review helpfulI've played alot of games... Alot of buggy, crappy games. But this one easily tops them all. My very first mission I found myself about 5 kilometres inland flying around some houses an bouncing off of the ground... I'm n... Read Full Review
2 of 2 users found the following review helpfulThe Good points The graphics are incredible. You are free to walk in the u-boat. You can talk to the characters and it feels quite realistic. The Bad points The game starts with a tutorial on how to use the u-boat, ... Read Full Review
5 of 6 users found the following review helpfulBefore I begin, I like many of you have seen the 1.0-2.0 abysmal scores on here and other sites. In all honesty it was because of this I was planning to give this a wide berth but being such an avid fan of SHIII and SHIV... Read Full Review
3 of 9 users found the following review helpfulThere is literally only one word that can be used to describe the release of Silent Hunter 5! Horrendous! This is the definitive proof that the PC gaming industry; needs a governing body to regulate companies like ... Read Full Review
11 of 12 users found the following review helpfulFirst off the DMR is ridiculous. Name one instance where it stopped pirating out right. You cannot. Name one instance where it stopped a paying customer from playing the game. Way too many times. Second off, I will ne... Read Full Review
11 of 12 users found the following review helpful
Log in to comment