Definetly not all its cracked up to be...
The gameplay is very simple. Hack and slash a few minions then get into a button-mashing sequence. The button-mashing sequences occur about every five minutes. They get extremely repetitive and old. It would be nice if there were some animation changes also. They all look they same. The gameplay is not well thought out at all. It is very dissapoiting.
The sound department is somewhat better. The voice actors and Kratos sound pretty flat. The music is suspensful sometimes. The battle sequences don't really sound that realistic or good for that matter. The weapns all sound the same and all the screams of pain coming from the enemies sound like the zombie grunts from "Dawn of the Dead".
Why everyone praises and says how good this game is, I shall never know. The game has repititive combat, a flat sound department, and an alright story.