All i can say about G3...well it has everything exept what really made gothic fun.

User Rating: 3.5 | Gothic 3 PC
That's right lousy combat. And when i say "lousy combat" i mean, the type of combat you usually get from a 1975 - 2D super mario game. Now you may think that this little thing can't ruin a game. Well, it can actually. It's the game's essence. What point of learning new skills(fight/combat/strenght, and so on) if they don't really show. Let me explain. The most common creature in the game...the wolf. After level 10 you can beat one empty handed. If you fight more than one wolf...let's say ouuu...two, the odds are GREATLY reduced. Plus, the "enemy" doesn't actually fight with you. As soon as you start swinging your sword it starts to back up....and back up...and back up....until it hits a obstacle or fall off the map.

Atmosphere & Immersion: 8/10
Graphics: 8/10
Sound: 7/10
Physics: 4/10
Replay value: 6/10
Value for money: 3/10
Bugs, Stability & Performance: 3/10