Not nearly as bad as people make it out to be.
Gameplay: Innovative. I love the horseback fighting as it fits into the game, and is actually FUN! The gameplay is also fun due to the fact that after you beat little missions, you get new weapons, which keeps you going for more. My only gripe is that the environment is very large, but VERY empty.
8/10
Graphics: Horrendous. They look horrible for the 360..they look like GTA graphics... Not much more to say.
6/10
Sound: Good. This is exactly what life would sound like if you were in western gunfights with indians and shotguns.
9/10
Value: It took about 6 horus to beat, and the side-quests were just too boring to do, so it's worth a rental. I wouldn't recommend buying this game, but definately rent it.
7/10
Tilt: FANTASTIC story! I haven't played a game like this...ever. The horseback riding, interesting story, and other components just make this game a must play.
9/10