Fantastic Gameplay, Felt just like it should. Story line was descent, but the length of the game was 10 hours @100%.
Gun Truly is the best game in this Genre simply because of the playablity, realism (Horses and Movement), and the cruel ways to take apart people/animals in this game.
For the current generation games, this looks fantastic, but for next gen, this does not look like it take any advantage of the next gens specs. The sound was nice, but the voice acting was off. For example, they often had a old western mans voice, for a young man in the game.
The game was way to short though and although a sandbox, it was a kids sandbox for an adult title. From beginning to end, less then 10 hours for 100% completion. You get guns and a horse for full completion, but you have nothing to do with them unless bandits jump you, then you can blow them to little bits with your new guns. But since you get no reward at the end of the game, it is hardly worth getting.
This is a definite rent game, but I would not recommend buying because of how short it is and it has very little, if any replay value.