Simple and fun. Greg didn't give it enough credit.
Pros- Big name hollywood actors. Tons of blood. Wide veriaty of weapons that are fun to use. Large open maps. GTA style free roam. Tons of side quests. Many have commented that the game is very short. The game is as short as you make it. You could blow through the main missions in one sitting. But, you could do all the side quests and wander around exploring. Which opens up hours and hours of extra game play. Quick draw slow motion is fun. 1st person view is helpful. And you drink whiskey for health.
I would also like to say that the game controls very well
Cons- Main missions can be completed in one sick day off from work. Graphics are not up to 360 standard. Some bosses are just plain rediculous and frustraiting (the priest dude on horse back who constantly heals himself). Game seems like a Red Dead Revolver rip off at times. I hate Chris Christopherson (a.k.a. Ned)
Final Word- All and all, this is a very fun violent game. The graphics are not as good as they should be, so you have to over look that. Greg from gamespot always gives great reviews, I just think he could have been alittle easier on this game cause it really is fun.