On nov 11 the covenant got OWNED
Gameplay - I only gave it a 9 (notice how I say "only", this game is great!) because the gameplay is essentially a revamped better version of the first game. However, many new things have come! Don't get me wrong though, gameplay is great! Dual-guns, fighting tactics, controls (how I love the trigger button) smart NPCs, especially if you choose legendary mode. Gameplay in this game feels like you're in the game,I think you should get the game for the gameplay itself, but then comes the graphics...
Graphics- Grahpics are 9/10. What more can I say here? Get the game yourself and see for yourself! Some picutres on gamespot don't look as high quality as the actual thing,the only thing too mention here is the cutscenes who have some pop up effects
Sound - The sound in the game is amazing, the unique gun shot for every vehicle and gun, and even when you melee an object, it makes a unique sound. The sound track is basically orchestra, but it fits the theme of the game, and really gets you into it. The sounds in this game beat any other game I've played
Value - Replayability is huge. Multiplayer mode is the greatest part of this game, and it's very satisfying. If you have a few friends, go and get Live, you'll increase you gaming experience by alot!
BUY or RENT - If you could give bungie more money just for making a good game, I would do it. Well, maybe not. But you get my point. Defenitly buy this game. If you're not into shooters, I still reccommend buying it, but you can rent it too.
PS. About the learning curve, you always are learning new tactics in the game, which adds to its great multiplayer mode (online and co-operative).