The Difference Between Old School and New School
Game design is the single reason why gamers who entered during the 4th generation will have trouble with Nintendo's cult classic. Today, games have save points scattered everywhere, which typically restore a character's HP. Newer games have a difficulty setting. Mix all that in with video walk throughs, online FAQs, and you got yourself a moderately easy game.
Earlier titles from the 3rd generation didn't have these options or assist tools. Games from this era were also a lot shorter, as the cartridges held a lot less data. Fans get their money's worth from a difficult game. Imagine if Icarus was a breeze, and could be beaten on the first play through in half an hour after downloading it on the VC. Anyone would clearly be disappointed. Games like Icarus, Contra, and Ninja Gaiden, all test your patience and focus. I find myself not focusing in a lot of current games, because I don't have to. I know the adventure is gonna be around 40 hours long, and feature save points around every turn. I don't need to be perfect. Kid Icarus tests players in many ways. Are you the type who will be frustrated when things don't go your way? Or will you re-group your thoughts and ask yourself what you can do differently the next time your in the same situation? Kid Icarus is beautiful because the game isn't difficult due to poor design. You can always critique your game play style and find a better way to advance through the levels. I prefer to spend time focusing and becoming a better player, and coming out feeling accomplished.
Kid Icarus is simple and challenging, which is what many great series consist of. Some players bash the sound and graphics, but we are talking about a game from 1986. The Japanese version had far superior sound (due to the Famicom Disk System's FM synthesis),not to mention save slots instead of passwords, so grab that one if your a die hard fan. The R&D development team that made this game, worked on titles such as Metroid, Dr. Mario, Duck Hunt,Excite Bike, Wario and other classic titles. Unfortunately, they don't receive the worldwide recognition that they should. I don't care too much about the casual versus hardcore fan argument, but I will tell you this, if you stick with Kid Icarus, there is nothing casual about you.