Mafia II's in-depth story and beautiful visuals are its highlight.
The good things in Mafia II:
-The absolutely beautiful visuals using an incredible physics and lighting engine.
-The in-depth storyline with its constant twists and turns and character development. You don't miss anything.
-The music that plays on the radio as you drive around.
-Personalizing and finding a favourite car to drive around is quite intriguing.
-The game's original soundtrack perfectly suits the mood and feel.
The bad things in Mafia II:
-Frustratingly placed checkpoints.
-Traffic AI has its faults and may result in head-on collisions, totaling YOU or your car.
-If you're picky at having your car in perfect condition at all times, lots of money will be spent repairing it due to how easy it is for another AI-controlled car to ram you.
-Somewhat unsatisfying ending.
-Some gameplay doesn't feel exciting enough and is a little too basic.
This game definitely gives me the vibe of an 8.2 due to its frustrating, minor flaws that affected the experience a little more than they should, but they don't outweigh the lasting effect and chilling story that you'll get from this game.
I'll have to round the score to 8 from 8.2 due to the rating system.