Great game for people just starting or for old players who want to get back into the fold...
User Rating: 8.5 | Magic: The Gathering - Duels of the Planeswalkers X360
Honestly this game is meant to introduce or reintroduce players to MTG. The problem with the GS review is that the author failed to notice the reason why you can create your own deck. The game is fully balanced, each deck is balanced in accordance with the other playable decks, the reason being is that it takes a long time to figure out how to properly make a deck, and new players would keep getting run over, get frustrated and quit playing. The point to having a balanced game is so that you can pick up magic easily, once you grasp the concept of the game you go out and by cards and make your own deck, or the same thing but online.
The game has vibrate colors, great music, its very fun off and online, however it can only keep you playing it for so long, id say after 10-20 hours unless your completely addicted you will get over it. So if your interesting in learning how to play, or just reliving the old glory days this game will be fun for you. However if your a serious magic player, don't waste your time with it, get real cards or play online, build your own deck, and enjoy the game for what it truly is. 
