2K Sports - good a always.
Graphics - They are awesome. You can recognize players without checking their name or something like that.
Music - Great soundtrack goes well with baseball action. Some of the songs are from unknown bands, but they are totally kick-ass.
Deep franchise mode - From the arena to managers desk, everything in franchise is deep and fun.
Highly addictive - this game will keep you glued to the screen because of fun baseball action, deep franchise and three leagues!
Custom difficulty - Too difficult? Too hard? Create your own custom difficulty. It helps a lot if you are hardcore player or a casual one.
The Bad:
Controls - Oh boy, believe me, they are stupid. You need a controler to play this game with full fun, but, even with the controller it's kinda stiff.
Glitches - They knock off the highly realistic gameplay. Players run around in circles, umpire doesn't react to outs and stuff like that.
Final score: 7.5 + high recommendation. Buy this game it's totally awesome!