If you never picked up the first game in this series (like me) but have played Paper Mario, you'll feel right at home.
Gameplay- 9- Everything in this game has a certain level of charm to it that really brings it past the level of being just another game. The mechanics of having to press different buttons to attack with different people does take a little getting used to, but isn't at all difficult, just different.
Graphics- 9- Everything is bright & colorful, much like a Mario platformer. For a 2D game, everything is really sharp, and shows that 2D games are far from dead.
Sound- 10- I think the game really shines in this department. The voices of the Brothers are funny, many familiar sounds are left intact, and this game really uses the stereo sound well.
Value- 8- 20+ hours gameplay is great for a handheld RPG
Tilt- 9- Why 9? Cuz its really fun!