Still not the college football I would expect. But when?
User Rating: 7.5 | NCAA Football 08 X360
NCAA 08 is an improvement over the previous year's version. The gameplay and animations seem to be smoothed and expanded, which help to make the actual gameplay more enjoyable. Recruiting has been expanded and will be highly addictive and in-depth for those who love to go thru the recruiting process every year. Visually, the game seems to be identical to the prior version...which is disappointing. Yet, most of all, I think the college atmosphere is severely lacking in NCAA 08. Crowds don't respond w/ that sort of "college noise/enthusiasm" and the pre-game commentary is stale.
I think that NCAA would be a good rent....you know, play it each day before the real games take place, play a friend, etc. But as far as owning it, I can't see myself doing that, as the game is not addicting enough (at this point) for me to start up a dynasty and play it nearly every day. That's why I'm going to pass again on NCAA 08 this year and go with a more solid 360 game in Madden 08. 
