Good game.
-Decent college atmosphere.
-Create a prospect feature allows you to create yourself and get selected by a school.
-The off season has the same amount of depth as any Madden game out there.
The Bad:
-Your receivers drop so many passes that after a while you'll either run with your QB or your RB. To make matters worse, it's way too easy to break a big run with both of them.
-The play clock always starts at like 25 seconds, which means that there are way too many snaps in a game to call it realistic. I once played a full length game, and the final score was something like 90-50. That's just wrong.
-The sound sounds kind of...low quality. I don't really know how to explain it.
The gameplay in NCAA 04 really takes away everything that could have made an awesome game. With games like 06 or 07 that just came out, I would say don't bother with this one until the price is down to like $2.