Good pace, good fun, despite a few flaws
I was shocked that EA could create a better sim of hockey than 2K Sports, but that seems to be the case here. I think it is in the overall pace of the game, and the incredibly intuitive new controls that separate it from the others. It allows the tradition use of the face buttons, but I recommend using the sticks for controlling the players and the puck.
Graphics in the game are fantastic. Animations are good, except for some quirky ones here and there. The movement of the puck and players is realistic, and the speeds are just right. Puck physics really come into play here, and it adds so much authenticity to the game, making it no longer an action game, but more of a simulation of hockey . . . justs what I want! Goalies now react to the puck. It deflects of them and other players, and anything it hits. This makes for a very unpredictable experience, but it also can lead to some frustrating goals . . .
Sounds are great. I have been both listening to the announcers and also turning them off to listen to on-ice sound effects. Both are very good and add to the experience. When you get tired of hearing Gary Thorn repeat the same phrases, try out the on-ice sounds. Players shout at one another, the skates cut and scratch the ice, and you can hear it all. Fans are also present and can be heard along with the rink specific organs, horns, etc. I was pleasantly surprised to hear the slamming of the penalty box door in Madison Square garden after I was sent to the box. Little things like this really make a game much better.
However, little things aside, the gameplay in NHL 07 is great, and I think the controls are the main reason for this. Player AI is alright, on offense especially, but once you rely on your AI defenders to protect your lead and your goaltender, you may get a little angry when they allow opposing forward to skate around them to the net. My experience with this hasn't been as drastic as some other players have experienced. Maybe it is my choice of defensive strategy? Maybe it's because of the way I take control over defensement at the right time? Whatever the case me be, this lack of defensive AI is really the only glaring fault in the game.
The interface is easy to navigate. Menus can be easily found and stats are right at your fingertips. A complaint I have is that often times tables extend beyond the edge of the screen, and if I wanted to compare stats, sometimes I cannot see the two onscreen at once.
The different modes of play are adequately done. I am sticking with Franchise, which is fine. Its not overly compicated or complex, but thats fine with me. A more GM-minded player might not find all the options there in GM mode. Also, I could have used some more stategies on the chalkboard. The ones available are nice and explained for any hockey illiterate players.
With Xbox Live! youcan play others, but it isn't a good setup, and there is a lack of online league options, It is really only for online pick up games, it seems. I haven't tried playing online, and likely wont be.
NHL 07 is a great game for hockey fans, whether you like the fast-paced action or the slower simulation. Finally, a hockey game that I can get into!