In my personal opinion, Phantom Brave is the best when it comes to gameplay in strategy/tactical rpgs.
For the most part, the only thing that bothered me in PB is the long dragged-out cutscenes. It's heartwarming sure, but please. Let's go on with it!
The commotion about the horrible 2-D graphics are totally misleading and who really cares about how realistic a character is in a video game anyway?
Do yourself a favor and buy this game....or you'll miss hundreds of hours of super fun leveling up-ness.