Lazy level design and hardcore dungeon crawling make this game a boring sequel to an awesome classic. Over-rated.
I love Pikmin and the gameplay has good basics, but it is not polished and show laziness and lack of creativity. The game creates a lot of frustration like pikmins falling from the platform for no reason, enemies attacking you as soon as the level starts or throwing your pikmins in the water with no way back, dungeons that you have to start all over because even though you managed to beat the boss, you didn't have enough pikmins to carry the treasure...
You have to have a predefined strategy for every level of every dungeon, whichis fun at the begginning but quickly becomes annoying.
So yeah, it's a bad review, sorry everyone but i think Nintendo can do much better than that. There are hundreds of better games out there, this one simply is lazy and lacks this polished gameplay Nintendo is famous for.