You want nice gameplay go for this game, you want graphics with bells and whistles go for FIFA09, that simple.
User Rating: 7.5 | Pro Evolution Soccer 2009 PS3
I have both FIFA09 and PES09, i love the graphics on fifa09 but i hate the sluggish movement of the players. I'm a little disappointed because i loved to see PES09 shine but surprisingly little to no improvements have been implemented. User interface on PES09 is bad, and beginning to play online is even worse, you have to sign up by providing Konami ID/GameID/Two passwords/email address i almost gave up playing online. I think next year PES would retire, I'm not buying the game before renting first or reading reviews first. Unfortunately there are few unintelligent reviewers who give any game they like 9-10, that's why i always read reviews below 8 only. I was hoping that PES would have learned something from FIFA08 (graphic) but my hopes went astray. There is nothing encouraging about buying the next release. 
