Such a controversial show - of course I have opinions. Please feel free to comment if you watch, too!

Regarding the Losties being traded for Walt:

I don't know what the deal was with the Others wanting Hurley and then ditching him. He was the hardest to convince to go with them and the Others should have known that would be the case, so why ask for him if they didn't want him at all?

I really want to know what they're gonna do with Kate, Jack and Sawyer. Do you think it has to do with their love triangle at all, or that they're the 3 strongest leaders on the island? It'll be very interesting to see what "psychological experiment" they fulfill.

There's no way they just gave Walt back. Something will happen to that boat - Michael's an idiot.

Regarding Penny:

Maybe Penny didn't actually find them. Maybe they found something else, but they just wanted to plant the seed that someone's looking for them, and using the right method to find them (knowing about the electromagnetic field). This brings some questions, though.

1. I thought those Russian guys were on a plane, but others are saying they think they were on the ground. If they're on the ground, where are they? How do you find someone without moving?

2. This is the first time they've shown present day footage of someone not on the island - are they going to bring that entire aspect into the show permanently?

3. Let's say Penny finds them, do you think people would actually leave? I think Jack really wants to know what's up. So does Locke, Ecko and maybe Desmond. I don't know if they'd allow themselves to be rescued. What if Penny comes to get him and she stays there to help them figure it out with her knowledge of her dad's side of everything? That'd be freaky.