AutoTaco / Member

Forum Posts Following Followers
747 11 5

Why Fate(Or God's Plan.) is BS...

There is something my mom used to say, "That God has a plan for all of us blah blah blah." essentially talking about fate. I was thinking on that and came to wonder, "So, then all those murders, rapists, serial killers, etc. were supposed to do such horrible acts?" This puts a bit of a moral and logical lapse in that statement, because well since God has a single plan for everyone then it would be purposely be sending people to Hell and making its own creations suffer. Yes, that makes sense.

God: Y'know what? I'm going to create some creatures in my image and love them and nurture them,etc. Now I'm going to inspire people or destroy their lives with some ungodly event!

How pissed off would you be if your purpose was to do one of those acts?

Man: (Melancholy) Sometimes I wish I knew what I was here for...(Shouting heavenwards.) What am I supposed to do?!

God: (In a formal manner) Well... in ten years after many failed relationships and personal tragedies you'll go bat **** insane and start raping and brutally killing 4 year old girls and then die in a car accident where you fly through the windshield and face first onto the pavement. And there's not a thing you can do about it.

Man: (Thinking)And what will that accomplish?

God: (Condescending, in a matter-of-fact tone..)So the mothers of the murdered can form a support group for those with similar experiences.

Man: (Feeling completely and utterly broken.).............I guess thats good...............................(Curls in a fetal position and cries knowing that he cannot stop himself from doing such horrible acts.)

This also means that since those people were supposed to commit these acts that there is no right or wrong. Fate doesn't allow right or wrong to exist because its all part of the plan. Not only that but it means there is no free will and we're all just some playthings for some outside force.

EDIT: This is speaking only of a singular fate. For all I know God just was bored and made us, or there is no outside force controlling everything, or it has multiple plans if on it doesn't go correctly.