For those of you who don't generally read the news page, allow me to refer you to
this news article. The short summary of the article is web site GayGamer.net, which claims to focus on game coverage taylored for homosexual people, particularly homosexual men, came up with a top 20 list of the top 20 homosexual characters in games. Unfortunatly, rather than the list having primarily characters which are actually homosexual, instead it's dominated by unfortunate cliches. Note for the record: I am not homophobic. I have no problems with homosexuality and I am in favor of legalizing gay marrage. However, I do have problems with people unnecessarily labeling fictious characters as gay, and this article goes so far into the realm of cliche and stereotype as to enter the realm of middle-school level immaturity. Now the list isn't entirely dominated by false positives. There are some characters on there that are actually homosexual. For instance, #12, Vamp from Metal Gear Solid II, does kind of work, if only because vampires do have a fair amount of eroticism attached to them. The drinking of blood and the biting of the neck has been described by not just literary critics, but by literary scholars as a erotic act, and in Bram Stoaker's Dracula (not just the film, but the novel as well), Dracula's bite causes his victim to experience a feeling of ecastacy. Also, the character of #9 (Ash from
Streets of Rage III) was obviously meant to be homosexual, as was #7 (Hana Vachel & Rain Qin from
Fear Effect II) #6 (Bertram from
Temple of Elemental Evil and #4 (Pierre and Gerard Magimel from the
Shadow Hearts games). #3s homosexuality is debatable, but as the character
is a vampire, there can be some leeway here. Also, #10 (Brad Evans from
Wild Arms 2) was part of a homosexual relationship (or strongly emplied homosexual relationship) in the Japanese version of the game with a fellow soldier named Billy, a relationship that was downplayed in the American release. So, no issues there. #8 (Damian Shade and Rudolph Gartheimer of Japan-only game
Groove on Fight) consists of another two characters who are described as gay (though, as the game was not released in the US I have to take their word, questionable as it may be, for it). The rest of the list, however, falls into cliche. #20 (Raphael Sorel of
Soul Calibur II & III) is described as gay solely because he is a bishounen and French. For those not familiar, the term bishounen is (obviously) Japanese and referrs to men who are beautiful in appearance (the term is derived from the Japanese word
bishoujo which means "beautiful" or "pretty"). Bishounen are generally meant to be the "ideal" in male attractiveness. Western women lust over men who show masculine traits physically, who are reasonably muscular (like Brad Pitt, or Russell Crowe or Colin Farrell) culturally. In Asian cultures, at present, men who are feminine
in appearance are considered attractive. Also, considering that #20 is a character from
Soul Calibur, putting it in a semi-Renaissance context, and that the character is a French noble, being feminine in appearance isn't entirely a negative for the time, as being muscular was something for peasants. Likewise for being tanned from the sun. Likewise, his swordfighting style is appropriate for the character and the time. Now, you could get freudian there, but once you get into Freud thing's get rediculous, and you could construe everything as being in some way construing homosexuality, so I'm not going to bother with Freud. #19 (Fox from the
Bloody Roar series) is described as gay primarily because the character dresses effemanately (high-riding shorts, and a top that resembles a bikini top). The writer of the article assumes that Fox is male. IIRC, the character of Fox is
female. Then again, the lack of stereotypically huge breasts common to females from Japanese fighting games may have thrown the writer of the article. #18 (Cybil Bennet from
Silent Hill) is considered to be a lesbian because she is a motorcycle cop. That's it. No further justification other then a bad stereotype perpetuated by the Village People. Now, if there was sort of storyline explanation for this this would be one thing. But they give none. Now, before you suggest that they may have been considerate and chose not to give out spoilers - they give plenty of spoilers for many of the other entries in the list. #17 (Nagare Namikawa from
Rival Schools 2) is considered to be gay because he is on the swim team. Again, the sole justification for being on the list is a stereotype. Let's move on. #16 (Alfred Ashford from
Resident Evil: Code Veronica) - Here they have some major spoilers for Code Veronica. By major I mean huge. Now, as this particular spoiler has, AFAIK, not be spoiled to the same degree as "Aeris Dies" has been spoiled, I'm going to
ROT13 it. If you want to read their justification for Ashford's inclusion, read the article. Anyway, vs Nyserq Nfusbeq vf tnl, gura Abezna Ongrf orybatf ba Dhrre Rlr. #15 (Eagle from
Street Fighter) can be given some leeway for that choice, as the character was re-designed for his return in
SNK vs. Capcom II to look more like the late Freddy Mercury, who was bisexual (which, in combination with his sexual promiscuity, may have signed his death warrant - but that's another matter). Other then that, the article's statements are based soley on fashion sense. #14 (Major Ivan Raidenovitch Raikov of
Metal Gear Solid: Snake Eater) is debatable. On the one hand, the character is a bit of a parody of Raiden from Metal Gear Solid II - who was derogatorily described as an effeminate pretty-boy by American fans. Also, the character is known for grabbing the crotch of male characters, and does have some dialogue implying that he may be gay. I'm going to semi-concede this one. He might be gay. He might not be gay. It's ambigous. #13 (Zangief from the
Street Fighter series) brings us back into the realm of cliche and stereotype. Basically, the character is gay because he's a muscular professional wrestler. #11 (Birdo from
Super Mario Bros. 2) leaves me scratching my head. The character's presense on the list is, basically, based on material which was
cut from the final approved version of the game's manual. As printed, the character is either female, or asexual, depending on how you consider it. So, the character really doesn't belong on the list. We have now, after a nice steady block of 6 characters who
actually are gay come to the Top Five. #5 is the King of All Cosmos - from
Katamari Damashi. The justification here is the character's beard, the fact that rainbows come out of his mouth when he speaks, his costume, and his attitude. My rebuttal, in short, is this - the Katamari Damacy games are exercises in sillyness. Reading anything into them is an exercise in futility. If you are looking at the characters trying to determine if any of them are gay or not, or even worrying about later, you're wasting your time. The creator no more meant to have the character be gay than Eric Idle meant to suggest to people that he was gay by playing all those female characters on
Monty Python's Flying Circus. #2 is The Cho Aniki Brothers - from the
Cho Aniki series. I don't know what to say about this. Judging from all the footage of the game and stills of the game from the site they linked to, I can best say in the arguement for why these characters
aren't gay is the game's creator made the game to make fun of all the people who either bother trying to figure out if a game character is gay, or make cliched homosexual game characters. #1 is Tingle from the latter (
Oracle of Ages on) games in the
Legend of Zelda series. Again, this one could be semi-debatable, except for one thing - where the Legend of Zelda series is concerned, Nintendo always tries to make the games family-friendly for both the Japanese and American market, both by not including graphic violent content, any sexual content (or anything that could be particularly construed as being sexual) or any particularly homosexual characters. While Nintendo may have tried to make Tingle "cute", and instead only made him "annoying". I doubt they were trying to make him gay. That's my run-down of the list. Feel free to post your comments - I'm interested in your input.
Log in to comment