The fine line between hack and genius
by Diela on Comments
At one time, my lifelong goal was to write screenplays for Hollywood. Maybe that was just an excuse to watch so many movies and television shows, but I applied myself with the diligence and fervor of the newly-converted. I tracked down Campbell's "Faces of the Hero", a writer's guide to archetypes in storytelling. I read a library full of fiction, and some non-fiction. I've watched many hours of television, both live and on DVD. I've revisited classics like "Kung Fu" and struggled with the over-acting in "Renegade". As I was watching "Threshold" the other night, I noticed they were introducing a minor mystery about one of the secondary characters... not a big mystery, but enough for me to take note of it. It got me thinking about "Lost" and how the main attraction of that show was the mysteries... what their character's backgrounds were, what the deal was on the island, was it natural or supernatural? And I realized how difficult it is to walk that fine line... Tell the audience too little about a character, to try and foster a great deal of mystery, and they become uninteresting and unsympathetic. The marine on "Threshold" missed running to someone's deathbed because he was on a mission. I realized I didn't really care, because I didn't know who it was, couldn't sympathize with him, because the only thing I knew about him was his ability to bark orders and shoot a gun. But the sword has a second edge... tell the audience too much about a character, and the questions are gone. They have no reason to tune in/read further because their questions have been answered. How interesting will "Reunion" be once we know who of the six friends was murdered? How easy will it be to deduce who killed them with the limited number of motives available to incite their death? It's a fine line, and the good writers must walk it like a tightrope balanced between a swamp full of crocodiles and a pool of sharks. It makes me question my own equilibrium as a writer, because I've seen and felt audience reaction when it's all gone wrong. I may not ever write a blockbuster movie, or the great American novel, but I'm still fascinated by their intricacies. To that end, I'd like to ask you all... What mysteries intrigued you about a show? What answered questions made you stop watching?
Log in to comment