Not really seeing the "PS5 got great exclusives" argument. So far there hasn't been one I was interested in. Meanwhile Xbox has Gamepass, Bethesda, currently Starfield, and great smaller games like hifi rush and Psychonauts which I find way more interesting than anything PS5 can dish up with, so I switched from PS4 to Xbox.
The value of Gamepass is crazy and you'll get to play so many great games.
There are just too many stubborn people out there refusing to see a great value.
Personally I've given up on relying solely on GameSpot scores and prefer the metascore from Opencritic for a more reliable assessment like imdb for movies. Individual reviewers are just too random, especially GameSpot these last years, glorifying indies and being too political.
So an 88/100 seems quite good. We'll see, not like it's going to cost me anything to try with Gamepass.
Djon's comments