Nintendo have been touting their upcoming Wii console as if it were the second coming of Jesus. Wii will apparently save us from the humdrum of joypads and we will all be jumping around like monkeys waving our arms around while its graphic intensive competitors gather dust on store shelves.
But is that going to happen. Are Nintendo going to be able make us feel part of the action. Will swinging our arms to the actions of a golfer, boxer or bowler actually going to make us feel part of the action more so than realistic graphics, ingenious AI and real time physics.
I am of course talking about the fourth wall, the single entity that prevents us from actually being part of the game. The wall that means we are not actually part of the action. That means we are not the Master Chief, not Mario and not Solid Snake.
This wall is present in all games but it would seem the sole purpose of video game evolution has been to destroy this fourth wall and make us feel a little but more like that dude on the screen.
It is clear that Nintendo are taking a very different view on how this fourth wall should be broken. Nintendo think innovative motion sensing controls are the future. Microsoft on the other hand think extreme power will lead to a more realistic game world. And SONY seems to think we need both in one console.
After playing Gears of War on XBOX360 the argument of which console is taking the right path has become more intriguing. At least to me.
Gears of War is probably the first 360 game you look at and just know that it is next generation. You just know that this game was built for next gen. and really takes advantage of what the 360 has to offer.
And when playing it this shows. The superb graphics, AI and particle effects all make you feel part of the action. You feel like you are Marcus Fenix. When a grenade goes off next to you it does make you squint. When you plough a chainsaw through someone’s chest it feels and looks real.
I am just not so sure that the Wii will deliver an experience above that of the 360. I am still not sure an innovative controller is going to make me feel more part of the action. After all, isn’t a complete redesign of the traditional joypad the least organic evolution there is?
If we have grown up with the joypad (of which Nintendo were one of the first to perfect remember) isn’t it very unnatural to completely alter the way we interact with games?
After all is said and done only time will tell which console delivers the most absorbing gaming experience. I am still a firm believer that the Wii will deliver a very satisfying gaming experience and that it will definitely prove itself as a innovative piece of kit. But I am not so sure it will deliver a more satisfying and absorbing gaming experience than the 360 and PS3 which have the advantage of extreme power on their side.
Log in to comment