Well I figured it was about time for another blog (this is the most posts in one blog I've ever had, I'm impressed with myself that I'm actually still here). Anyway a word of warning: this blog will be all about the Mass Effect Revelation book that I finished reading this weekend, and as such it will include numerous SPOILERS. So if you haven't read the book or don't like spoilers then read no further.
************************************************************************************
Well first impressions of the book were adequate. I liked the setup, the explanations, and the build up to the main story. It also gave me a good sense of how the conversations in the game would be played out. I'm really looking forward to going to some of the same places from the book in game, so hopefully BW will include at least one planet from the book. I found Anderson to be an interesting and fairly likeable character. Kahlee was probably my favorite character from the book, with Skarr coming in a close second. I hated, and I mean really hated, Saren. I didn't like the way his character was written, I didn't find his actions to be believable. It felt like the book was trying to make everyone hate Saren while at the same time trying to give some shades of grey to Saren's evil, but in my opinion the whole thing failed miserably. Saren's whole motivation for hating humanity for killing his brother in the First Contact war seems trite and overdone. Lots of people lost family and friends in that war, but somehow Saren is the only one that matters? The fact that everything he did was "for the Council" was complete and utter bs. I don't know if the book was trying to make Saren hypocritical, or if that was an attempt at portraying Saren as doing the good thing no matter what the cost, either way I didn't like it. Everything Saren did or said grated on my nerves and I really just want him to die, so I guess in that aspect the book really got me even more excited about the game. I can't really believe that Saren was a Spectre. I mean with all the intensive training and testing possible members have to go through they couldn't possible miss the fact that Saren is psychotic, and no matter how great his results the Council doesn't seem stupid enough to keep a psychotic Spectre.
Now for character interactions. I already said that the book gave me a good sense of what conversations in the game would be like. By that I mean that when reading the dialog in the book I could just imagine the different possibleresponses that would be available in the game if that conversation was taking place. However alot of the relationships between the characters seemed rushed or fake. Well not alot of the relationships, really just the "romance" between Anderson and Kahlee. The whole thing seemed like it was forced, like Drew had to include some romance, and Anderson and Kahlee being the only available characters were just pushed together. I also didn't like the whole secret that Kahlee was keeping from Anderson. Again it seemed forced just to add some drama and conflict to the "budding relationship".In fact the whole book seemed like it was rushed to me, and I would have liked it to be alot longer.
The action scenes were impressive, but to me it seemed like Drew was really focused on the action and everything else was second thought.
All in all the book was okay. I almost didn't finish it because I lost interest but I had already read two thirds of the book and I didn't want the time I spent reading to be wasted by not finishing. I think the book needed to be longer, with more focus on the characters and their interactions and motivations. For an introduction to the Mass Effect universe the book serves its purpose, and I did like the details provided about the Council, the ships, and the history. The writing itself was smooth enough, but again, everything felt like it was rushed, rather that was pressure from the publisher, the editor, or just Drew's writing style I don't know. To me it felt like the story would have been better as a game than a book, but that could be my impatience to get Mass Effect. In the end I think Drew's style lends itself better to games than books, but I think he's had more experience writing for games so that's understandable. I wish the book had been longer, and more indepth, but again Drew was writing for a specific audience which probably kept the length down, and he also couldn't get too detailed without giving too much about the game away. It's a decent read to pass the time and it provides a nice introduction to the ME universe, but it is not something I would suggest to someone who wasn't waiting for ME, and if the game was being released sooner I probably wouldn't have read it. My final recommendation is, if you're really looking forward to ME, then check the book out, butI wouldn't tell anyone tobuy it, if possible I would say to borrow it from a friend or a library if your library carries those sorts of books.
Later,
FLCL
P.S. - Sorry if any of that didn't make sense, sometimes I find it difficult to fully describe what I mean or think about a book. If you have any questions about my opinions or you disagree with anything I've said,feel free to PM me.
Log in to comment