@mogan: Nope, not if the review is bad. The fact that GS is a gaming website does not excuse them for failing to do their reviews well. I can finally admit that GS has been going overboard with bad reviewing for the last three years, to say the least. It doesnt matter that GS is a gaming website that has been running decades, they can now be bad at reviewing. In the same sense, it doesnt matter that Don Mattrick was a product leader, he was still awful when launching the XOne. It doesnt matter that Scorsese has won Academy awards and is originally a great moviemaker, The Irishgarbage is an abominable trash of a movie. It doenst matter that Trump is president, he is still bad as a leader overall. See my point here?

While you are right when you say that it is lame to get upset or insult (you are 1000% RIGHT on that one), it is the overall sense of your argument that i find inaccurate because you are ignoring the quality of the review and that is not an objective way to address this discussion, in my respectful opinion. I say this because, to me, you are probably the best and/or most present moderator here at GS. As such, you should be allowed to use objectivity (which you do use in every other type of articles here, it is just the reviews you tend to permanently defend). For the record, i say this with the utmost respect for you. I am not a troll.

It is because you avoid the quality of the review that i find your comment a bit biased, thats all. You are right on the second part, but the fact that you dont challenge the review causes an impact on the overall sentiment that you are trying to communicate.

@bdrtfm: NMS is not a good example. You make a good point nevertheless. It’s just that the case of NMS was different, thats all :)

Well, i will seriously consider not coming here anymore.

@Atzenkiller: why?

CSR. Good, but also a strategy :)

@gaeandilth: very ignorant comment. Sorry, had to state the obvious.

@louixiii: good point (not trying to get in the middle of this btw)

@bdrtfm: not trolling at all, but i have to say my PS4 works fine offline. All of my games work perfectly. Sekiro, Nier, Death Stranding, TLoU, Persona 5R, RE2, Spiderman and many more, i dont write all of them because im not bashing or trying to fanboytize my argument. You may have a point. For real, you may have a point. But when you say "Take your PS4 offline" it really doesnt explain the reality of things. Again, not trolling at all, just clarifying :)