Does GTA IV really deserve a 10?

I have the game, ive played through it. I liked it a lot and I enjoy the online, but 10 means perfection, in my opinion this game is not perfection, the graphics, and controls for example. Personaly i think it deserves a 9.5 and the only reason it got so high ratign was from all the attention the GTA series gets due to negative publicity.

I come to the general games disscusion for non bias opinions, what do you all think?

[QUOTE="neXtgenisis"]

......there is enough money to buy everything in the game unless u get 5 stars on hard. and thats hard how do u buy guitar, finishes, song, characters, and outfits if u get 350 bucks for a 4 star sreformance i think they should have gave more money

jmartinez1983

You get money for each time you do the song don't you? So you could just keep doing the songs you are good at to get more money. This shouldn't be a big problem.

No you on get money if u get higher star rating 

Take my word for it, go LIVEEEEEEE!!!!!

Think of it as a more in depth better looking  and more fun to play saints row, and you get super powers!!!

AND POSSIBLY HALO 3 BETA :P

Not to flame or anything, but that was pretty bad.

The sound coagulated together (music + sound effects) making it an assault on my ear drums.

The picture could have been a little better.

but the biggest thing... it was campaign, nothign really exciting going on.

But for a first vid i guess it was alright, keep trying.

thanks