This is the game review outline I just came up with. I feel like it covers the vital details that people need to know about a game. It also gives me the chance to thoroughly and thoughtfully analyze what I think about the game I'm reviewing. My goal behind this is to keep me focused and on point while I write as well as making it easy for the people reading to follow.
Maybe this will be of some use to future review writers as well?
I wrote a (massive) review for Elderscrolls IV: Oblivion using this format. Check it out here and let me know what you think!
Any suggestions you guys have would be greatly appreciated and are always welcomed. ;)
Setting:
Where does the game take place and why?
Intro:
This section will cover how I feel about the game and what I expect of it before I actually play.
Main Menu:
I'm very intrigued with how developers set up the main menu of a game as it is typically the first thing players will get to interact with. The menu can sometimes be a precursor to how good the game itself may or may not be. (May omit this section in certain reviews.)
Opening Cut Scene:
This section will cover how I feel about the opening cut scene as it is usually designed to 'sell' the game to players. (Will omit this section when non-applicant.)
First Impression:
This section will cover how I feel about the game after navigating it's menus, getting past the opening cut scene, and heading out of the tutorial.
Graphics:
How does the game look in regards to the visual design the developers were aiming for? Did they use the system's graphical power to it's full potential? Did they deliver unique and appealing visuals? Did they take full advantage of the system's graphical strengths? Was there any visual chugging or 'lag' at some points? Etc...
Physics:
(A more specific extension of the graphics section.) Do things move they way they should in the game? Do things seem to have 'real' weight? Is momentum present? Does the wind affect things? Do things break accurately? Is the destruction of the same item unique each time? Etc... (Will omit this section when non-applicant.)
Controls:
How easy are the controls? Do they fit for the kind of game it is? Hardest part about them? Easiest part about them? Customizable? Annoying? Etc...
Artificial Intelligence:
How does your team respond to certain situations? Do the NPCs act natural? Are your team members and enemies as smart as they should be? Etc...
Difficulty:
This section will cover if the game's difficulty was fitting, too hard, or too easy based on the options they give you.
Storyline & Plot:
This section will detail the game's plot and story, without revealing any spoilers. Graded on originality, creativeness, believability, and delivery. Any plot holes? Is the writing good or subpar? Etc... (Will omit this section when non-applicant.)
Voice Acting:
This section is very important to me as bad voice acting has ruined many potentially great titles in the past. This part of a game can truly affect the overall experience, so I feel it is my duty to let people know when bad voice acting is apparent. (Will omit this section when non-applicant.)
Sound, Music & Ambiance:
This section will detail how good the music for the game is, if it is fitting, and how well they incorporate it into the gameplay. It will also detail the sound effects you hear not only from the character, but the things around the character as well.
Game Development & Delivery:
This section will cover how the game develops. Is is too slow paced? Is it too fast? Did they do a good job of making the game unfold smoothly. Does it portray things in the manner that the game designers intended, or was it off a bit? (Will omit this section when non-applicant.)
Unique Features:
This section will detail anything about the game that sets it apart from the others, new things they might have tried, and how they incorporated those features into the game.
Ending (No Spoilers):
This part will explain how I felt after playing the game all way through. Did it leave me wanting more? Was it overrated? Climactic finish? Was I satisfied with the outcome? Etc... (Will omit this section when non-applicant.)
Replay Value:
Does this game offer anything that would make the player want to play again, or does it force you to go back through it to obtain certain things? Is it fun to play over and over? Is there anything that makes you want to go back time after time?
Multiplayer/Online Features:
Does the game offer competitive or cooperative play? How many can play? Is it fun online, or frustrating? Are there leader boards? Can you play split-screen? Can you take a guest online? Are the multiplayer/online modes fitting the type of game it is? Etc... (Will omit this section when non-applicant.)
Strengths:
What was the game good at and why was it good?
Weaknesses:
In what areas did the game lack and how could they improve?
Summary:
This section is for people who don't feel like reading all of the detailed junk above. They can simply scroll down to here and get the 'at-a-glance' version of everything.
Miscellaneous Info:
Anything else worth mentioning will be here. Like if it displays in 1080p or not. If it has DLC. Etc...
Log in to comment