Uhhh....What you describe is people having personal opinions. It's the same as you describing people who are disappointed (and are willing to express this disappoint) in this game as being "wrong".
LOL. That's gamers for you; we simply can't accept anyone who expresses differing opinions than our own. I must say, I'm quite embarrassed to remember that I, too, behaved in such a manner. Hell, I probably still do.
All the usual criticisms/demands are present in these comments. You have people boldly---not boldly, since it's easy to make such demands when you're an anonymous user----demanding that Kevin be fired for his review score (LOL! Seriously!), which isn't even that bad (as you too acknowledge). You have others using the age old tactic of bringing up different review scores for other games, which were likely written by "different" reviewers, as a means to discredit "this" review. "They gave Halo a 9+, why not this!?" Hilarious. There's even the mention of "bribes" to rate games higher. So........If bribes are required to rate games higher, should I consider this review honest?
I bet the GS reviewers get a kick out of reading these comments.
Herenr's comments