My only complaints with WW and TP was that they lacked any semblence of challenge, and that dampers a game for me. I still own both games, and play them routinely for their finer points, but Zelda III A Link to the Past is and will always be the perfect zelda game IMO. For the record, i couldn't finish Phantom Hourglass, it was just too boring. Not to say its a bad game, i gave it a fair chance, but after 5 or 6 hours i was done.