I come not to bury Gamespot, but to praise it.
Like all entities, Gamespot was defined by its personalities, the names and faces breathing life into an otherwise soulless collection of news and information. In the first few steps it took, I was a casual purveyor, still bound to the printed media I was able to take with me into the bathroom. Again and again I found myself returning, eventually becoming reliant on it for all things gaming. I became a total access subscriber the month they launched it, lauding the features and content to all my friends, watching proudly as the site grew and the faces emerged. Then the inevitable happened; the faces began disappearing. First Carrie Gouskos left, then Greg Kasavin. Wham. Bam. Luckily, some new faces arrived and all was right in the gaming world, for a while. And then Rich Gallup left, and I felt like I had lost a friend.
Then the unthinkable happened; Gamespot took a knife to its own face. The sacking of Jeff Gerstmann alone was a horrible experience, but to happen in such a seedy, "corporate politics" manner made it even worse. The way CNET handled the aftermath was abominable. And then it went from bad to OMG. All the faces started leaving.
That's when I went from sad, to putting a chip on my shoulder. I started looking for excuses to leave Gamespot. I set up an account over at 1up. That chip sat there uncontested until one day when I was perusing some old posts, and noticed that I never responded to an older forum topic. I hardly ever post. Low and behold, I received a message informing me that I had been moderated for "disruptive behavior" for reviving an old post. Now, I am no stranger to Internet etiquette, but this one was news to me. Why even keep old posts available to comment on if it's such a rotten thing to do?
Somebody had jostled my chip.
I knew right then what I had to do. It was time to commit account suicide. I went straight to the mod boards and posted a completely frivolous response to my moderating, knowing exactly what kind of fish I expected to hook. A sucker took the bait and I promptly canceled my subscription. It felt good.
It still feels good.
In 1992, several talents within the comic book industry decided they were through giving up there creations to Marvel Comics. They formed Image Comics, the fourth largest publisher in the industry today and arguably, the happiest. I feel the vibrations of a similar event happening here, today, with Ryan "Liefeld" Davis and Jeff "McFarlane" Gerstmann starting their own site, free from the trappings of marketing pressure and soulless corporate policies. That's something I want to be a part of, and I fully plan on embracing everything they have to offer.
The one I feel really bad for is Ryan MacDonald. He's like the green crystal in the Fortress of Solitude, the one with all the knowledge of a world long dead, a fraction of its power, singing with the voices of the past. Although Ryan moved away from the camera to allow Rich and Jeff the spotlight, he is the one I always associate as the heart of Gamespot. Only through him and Ricardo Torres can Gamespot recover, and I wish them the best.
Log in to comment