I'm tempted to say that this was the best E3 I have seen. So many games, a lot of big announcements, and a return to the old (bigger) format. It's definitely made me reconsider what games I'm looking forward to most. This list is one of the hardest I've ever had to put together. Cutting this list down to my top 5 was extremely difficult, but here they are in ascending order:
5. Splinter Cell: Conviction
Any number of games could have gone in this slot, but I chose Splinter Cell because of the drastic changes that the team at Ubisoft have made to the Splinter Cell formula. You now are much more equipped to take enemies head on, but you can also do the stealth bit if you want to. A couple of slick new design choices, like displaying mission objectives right on the environment (like on the side of a building that you have to infiltrate, for example), seamless transitions from cutscenes, and the "last known position" feature (puts a silhouette where the enemy last saw you, which you can then use against them) make this extra appealing.
4. Left 4 Dead 2
I'm still playing the original (at least I was until my xbox red ringed last week) and it shows no sign of getting boring soon. This was one of the big shockers at E3 for me. I'm so happy it's getting a sequel so soon. The promise of melee weapons, more campaigns, more story, a new set of survivors, and Valve as the developer make this a guaranteed purchase for me.
3. Halo: Reach
This was a shock announcement from Bungie. I thought they would keep the focus on ODST that's releasing this fall, but they decided to tease a new Halo game. It's a prequel to the original Halo and seems to follow the plot of the Eric Nylund novel "The Fall of Reach". Can't wait to hear more about this.
2. Heavy Rain
This is one of the most unique games I got the chance to see at E3. It's much less a game and more of an interactive story, but that's what makes it even more appealing to me. You basically control four characters and, depending on how you go about doing things (the ultimate goal is to catch a serial killer that all four characters are somehow connected to), you will end up with a different story. You can even let characters die. If all four characters die, then that's just how the story ends. There's no game over screen. The only thing keeping this out of the number one spot is the plot itself. It seems to be a bit generic and none of the characters seem that interesting, but the prospect of being able to mold the story to how you see fit almost completely makes up for it.
1. Alan Wake
This was my #1 going into E3 and it, barely, still holds that spot after it. It's been a long time since anything new was shown, but a stage demo gave me confidence that this is going to be one amazing game. The plot seems compelling (a horror novel coming to life? Yes, please), the lead character is interesting, the mechanics are unique (using light to take the darkness off of things, including enemies, which makes them vulnerable to damage), and the setting is absolutely creepy. If all goes well this is going to be a future GOTY contender.
So there you have it, my most anticipated games. This E3 has shown just how strong the industry is. Hopefully it will only get better. I had a lot of fun watching the Gamespot live coverage and talking in the chatroom. Really looking forward to playing the games we've seen over the last few days. Until next time, keep your bank accounts full.
EDIT: I'm not sure how I managed to do this, but I unintentionally left Uncharted 2 off of the list. Since I've already got 5 on there I'm just going to turn this into a top 6. So the list would go like this:
1. Alan Wake
2. Uncharted 2
3. Heavy Rain
4. Halo: Reach
5. Left 4 Dead 2
6. Splinter Cell: Conviction.