By now, if you're the obsessive gaming geek that I am, you've no doubt read the recently released (And apparently infamous) Xbox One review at Wired's website. If not, do so now since what I'm about to say within this blog post will not make sense otherwise. Their review, although a bit too brief and lacking in details for my taste, reveals some very startling facts about Microsoft's new machine that many are having a hard time understanding. These revelations, which consist of removed features and functionality, didn't have the same effect on me. If anything, their inclusion (Or perhaps lack of inclusion) merely supports my long held theory that Microsoft distrusts the user and endeavors to remove power from the owners of their devices for fear of them gaining control over the experience.
Grandiose claims coming from a lowly geek on a gaming blog, right? Not so, considering not only the track history Microsoft has of doing such things but also the degree of functionality removal present in the new Xbox One. After all, how can you explain away the absence of hard drive space reporting in the new console? Or the fact that the system will auto-delete older games you no longer play to make room when you need to? Or that the remaining charge within our controller battery isn't viewable in the GUI by any means? Or that the voice command module is so incredibly sensitive and ill-planned that other players can shut your system down through declarations made through their headset?
It's easy to read the previous paragraph and dismiss me as a rabble-rousing Playstation "fanboy", but the truth is I'm not. I always buy every console and enjoy them all equally. Though I'm primarily a PC gamer, I do frequently engage in console play when the right games emerge for them. I enjoy their ease of use, their simplicity and their JRPG-heavy libraries. Unfortunately, as these consoles become more and more like small form-factor PCs I have watched the honeymoon period with them end and a new age of complexity and failure begin. Though the new Playstation seems to retain the essence of the typical gaming console (for the most part, anyway), the Xbox is looking more and more like a PC.
...and much like the PC, Microsoft seems intent on preventing you from learning how to use it or understanding how it works.
Simply put, Microsoft has had a long held belief that taking power and usability away from the user is a beneficial tactic to take when developing new operating systems. Like the Xbox One's OS, Microsoft Windows has undergone a very similar downgrade through the years. Whether it was the removal of DOS, the ever-thinning options in the control panel, relegating popular features to unspoken command line options, or Microsoft's purchasing of Skype resulting in dozens of removed features (Editing Skype chats, notification of chat connection confirmation, inability to remove individual Skype chats), Microsoft has proven that they simply do not trust the user to be the caretaker of their own devices.
Why is this so, you ask? To again keep it in simple terms, Microsoft doesn't want you to dominate the experience. It isn't so much about believing you lack the ability to work your devices, especially given that my two-year-old nephew is already using an ipad, but it's more about making sure you do not modify the experience their well-paid researchers decided was best for you in their behavioral studies.
This is also why Microsoft is so "Anti-PC Gaming", since it's nearly impossible to control a PC gaming environment where modding and hacking are so common and inevitable. They need utter and complete control over your experience and believe that keeping you focused on a very limited and restrictive "spotlight" width of options will allow them to fully dictate what you see and do on their service while also giving you the illusion of freedom. Granted, it's their right since it's their service and their device, but that doesn't stop it from being unfair.
We'll see how this pans out over the next few months as people get their new consoles, though if the reaction online is any indication, it seems people are getting fed up with Microsoft's anti-user antics.
Log in to comment