I've played Rome: Total War and the Barbarian Invasion Expansion Pack, Empire: Total War, and Napoleon: Total War. Out of those, I would 100% say Rome. Empire didn't work on my pc (it kept freezing), and Napoleon was a complete let down. However, what I've seen on Medieval 2 (which should arrive tomorrow (ebay)), I would say that Medieval 2: Total War is the best Total War game, without a doubt.
Log in to comment