It is amazing how disturbing it can be to see a world you thought you knew so well unearthed, and just beneath the surface is ugly, sickening corruption. I had never thought I'd ever feel that way about the games industry, and yet here I am.
For articles pertaining to the dismissal of Gamespot's Site Director, Mr. Jeff Gerstmann, click here.
I really liked Jeff and his reviews, personally. But whether or not you enjoyed his writing has absolutely nothing to do with it. Jeff always, always wrote with a sense of honesty. He was always true to his experience with the game and never bowed down to external (and unfounded) expectations of a game. Kane and Lynch's review was no exception - he wasn't pleased with the game, and so it got a 6.0 / 10, meaning 'fair' on the Gamespot system.
Of course, the outcome was anything but fair. In exchange for doing his job as an objective writer and giving an honest evaluation of the game based on his experience with it, Jeff Gerstmann was fired.
Mr. Gerstmann (as well as Mr. Kasavin, who left the site by choice in January of this year) were the two people who convinced me that reviewing games was something worth pursuing, either professionally or purely for personal enjoyment. But the reason I wanted to pursue critical writing like product reviews was because it helps people choose something that will entertain them.
Escapism is not so very bad. Games have helped me through lots of difficult times in my life - it used to feel weird to say that, but it's the truth. What happens when the place you go for entertainment turns out to be just as corrupt as the rest of life, though?
It's hard not to feel pretty lousy about this. It doesn't matter if you knew Jeff's work or even if you play video games. No matter what lens you view it through, this is a sad time for journalism.
I'm going to stick around a while, if only to see if any more closure is reached on this situation. After all's said and done with the whole ordeal though, it seems only right to leave Gamespot. To support honest members of the industry like Jeff, and to support integrity in a line of work that is very susceptible to corruption.
Every single member of the Gamespot editorial team is a fantastic writer and a strong voice in games journalism. I wish them all the best and, hopefully, a job in the future with a stronger company who will take better care of them than CNet and Gamespot.
I've been coming to Gamespot.com for the last six years, and it has been one of my only sources of gaming news. I've read thousands of reviews and written a couple dozen of my own, too. I've watched hundreds of hours of videos. But ultimately, it's about the hobby, and there is an undeniable feeling that Gamespot is no longer looking out for the people who matter.
The slow departure of many Gamespot editors over the past year or two has been a strange but natural change for the site. But, this is a change that is most unnatural. And it feels wrong to stay. Thank you to the people who have read my thoughts in this blog, who have read my reviews, to the Community Contributions Union for helping me with my writing, and thank you to the Gamespot of old.
Goodbye, and all the best! I hope to see some of you on other sites all around the internet.
- Adam Schedler (September_Grey).
Log in to comment