NBA 08s look like intentional caricatures

Never played the original, my first experience was San Andreas, which I though t was overrated when I started, but I by the end I understood what people thought was so amazing about GTA. THe variety in dumbfounding. Plus, the talk radio is hilarious

THis is kind of a weird feature to have on gamespot. Are they going to do this with every genre?

Xbox is screwed in Japan, Sony screwed itself in Europe, which means the winner has to be Wii. Right?

Looking at all these forum posts, I retract my Sup Com statement. Jeez people, its just a list. So you're personal favorite wasn't on the list. boo hoo. This is just the most wanted game from each editor. MGS4 apparently wasn't #1 on anybody's list( If greg or carrie were here it would be), go figure. it was probably number two or three on a lot of lists. If you made a list and an editor's fave game wasn't on it, they would have enough class to not yell out their favorites in exclamation marks and annoy everybody.

I bet about 50 people already said this, but Sup Com anyone?!!!

Way to make it a bias free roundtable with two diehard Bears fans and a Colts hater/Pats lover guys. Colts by 17. The score difference probably won't be that big, but I feel bold.

[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]

EDIT: Oh wait, I'll trade Tetris for Pokemon Gold. And why is everyone listing SSBM? Its an amazing multiplayer game but in case you forgot YOU'RE ON A DESERTED ISLAND

1.Civ 4(never played it) 2.WoW(never played it) 3.tetris 4. NBA Live 2004(man that game was awesome) 5. Tony Hawk's Project 8(man that game looks awesome)